Hacker News

Datasets for Reconstructing Visual Perception from Brain Data

37 points by katsee ago | 7 comments

mitthrowaway2 [-]

Is there a case for non-dystopian applications for such a project, should it succeed?

I get that we're all driven by curiosity, and the brain is very mysterious, but at some point I really wonder when scientists will start to taboo projects like this for ethical reasons, just like they currently taboo human cloning.

td2 |root |parent |next [-]

I dont know anything about neurosience But if dreaming is related enouth to visual perception, maybe a dream recorder might be somewhat possible

td2 |root |parent [-]

Edit, reading the github description, which i should have done sooner, hints at dreams.

bensyverson |root |parent [-]

Every researcher working on this should be required to watch Until the End of the World.

katsee |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Reconstruction of inner experience - imagery, maybe dreams & hallucinations, perceptual phenomena.

Here is a recent study reconstructing the inner perception of optical illusions: https://www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/sciadv.adj3906

Methods like MVPA (decoding among finite sets of cognitive state classes) are actually widely used for insight in cognitive neuroscience.

Ethical concerns are discussed within the field; most papers had explicit ethics sections and discussions long before AI conferences required them for all submissions. In practice these experiments require a participant lying motionless (≈1-2 mm range) in an MRI scanner with controlled gaze and attention for many hours, and even then zero-shot reconstruction is not really possible; the SNR requires many repetitions.

aspenmartin |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Dystopian applications are extremely impractical or impossible, this is a tool for neuroscience

MarcelOlsz |root |parent |previous [-]

Not since Americans imported the Nazis - Von Braun et al.