Hacker News

A martian rock has lots of carbon on it, and it's not clear why

36 points by Brajeshwar ago | 4 comments

arbol |next [-]

They talk about bringing these samples back to earth but don't mention how. Have they already planned how to get perseverance and its samples back?

zokier |root |parent |next [-]

There was a plan for Mars Sample Return mission. But it got scrapped by budget cuts/concerns.

https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/mepagapril2025/presentatio...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA-ESA_Mars_Sample_Return

ButlerianJihad |root |parent |previous [-]

I don't see any need to retrieve entire rovers after their deployment on the surface of Mars, no matter how much they themselves beg and plead for us to do so...

https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=gNwkawLGDkg&si=Nh-tLcjdJdH...

metalman |previous [-]

"not clear why", by which I guess the implied ask is how it got there, which is likely because the universe has a bunch of carbon in it, and a whole other bunch of ways of distributing it, while also making and remaking it via a couple of other processes that the universe has running,

but the real ask, is the martain carbon concentrations derived from life, like the very random rock my left shoulder is leaning on, with whit patches, speckled with black dots, not counting the lichens, clearly also making the rock there home. and that answer will probable come from someone going to mars and doing a few simple tests. Mars ho!