Hacker News
Bilingualism and Denaskuleco
PowerElectronix
|next
[-]
It's not the native language of anyone, especially in the family so they are not going to be as exposed to it as one would in a family with a non- english native. And then there's no esperanto anywhere else so they are going to learn quickly they don't need it at all except for when daddy says something in esperanto.
odyssey7
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
Esperanto in this case is less of a gift to the child, and more of a self-expression of the parents’ worldview.
The author kind of acknowledges something about this.
> In Canada, it would make a lot more sense to raise the kids speaking French. If I had been more organized and forward-thinking, I could have raised them as native French speakers. I would have needed to prepare and study French but that didn’t even occur to me when Mira was born. I was fluent in English and Esperanto, I wanted Mira to be bilingual, and so I taught her Esperanto.
I don’t buy this argument. It boils down to, yes it would have been better to teach a different language, but the parent didn’t want to do the work of learning French, so the child got something that wasn’t nearly as beneficial instead. Children are capable of acquiring a second language for quite a bit longer than it takes a committed adult to become fluent in French.
lixtra
|root
|parent
[-]
It’s a risky bet, but it’s totally fine to take it.
odyssey7
|root
|parent
[-]
Why gamble on your child’s behalf that their life will be better off for knowing one of the very few rare languages that do not come with any of those benefits? So you can feel cool at Esperanto conventions? If you teach them Polish instead, for example, then they will have a lot of opportunities to eat pierogis and could someday meet the love of their life on a vacation in Poland — sounds a like a much safer gamble to make on your child’s behalf than to dedicate their critical period to Esperanto conventions.
lIl-IIIl
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
Most Esperanto natives are from parents who don't speak each other's native language and use Esperanto to communicate.
senorrib
|root
|parent
[-]
TFNA
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
tgv
|root
|parent
[-]
TFNA
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
Viliam1234
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
Here are some media in Esperanto:
jareklupinski
|next
|previous
[-]
now that im surrounded by Americans, its much harder to justify the mental load of teaching a non-scholastic second language when there is no community to reinforce what youve learned beyond rote learning exercises. im not convinced multiple languages made me smarter either...
joshdavham
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
I used to work in the language learning space, and I personally think that the idea that speaking multiple languages makes you smarter is mostly a myth. It definitely does expand your mind a bit and gives you the ability to express some ideas more concisely, but I don’t feel like it’s made me smarter in the same way that learning to code, or reading books has.
TFNA
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
Recently I learned Arabic to directly work with some sources in my branch of academia, and to be a better guest who can make some basic conversation when I travel to über-hospitable Arab countries. But going through the reading selections in my Classical Arabic textbooks revealed a whole canon of interesting literature on Middle East and world history over centuries. I have been eating that stuff up, and I probably never would have learned about it through languages I already knew; indeed a striking amount has never been translated.
dashee
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
I suppose you could liken it to eating nuts more regularly. It might not make you feel healthier, but physiologically it is doing that.
joshdavham
|root
|parent
[-]
I’m willing to accept it, but I’m more skeptical of multilingualism actually making one smarter or otherwise more cognitively capable.
And that’s a good analogy about eating nuts. It’s possible that while acquiring a second language could make you smarter, it might not subjectively make you feel smarter.
usermyuser
|next
|previous
[-]
joshdavham
|root
|parent
[-]
I think the online community of productive, computer/math nerds is actually quite small haha