Hacker News

Bullet Dodged

47 points by surprisetalk ago | 44 comments

ballmerpoint |next [-]

Kinda rude to insult the mechanic who uploaded a repair video to the internet that saved the author between hundreds and thousands of dollars.

petermcneeley |root |parent |next [-]

mushmouthed is not an insult

dcrazy |root |parent |next [-]

It’s definitely got negative connotations.

I originally had the same reaction as GP, but upon reflection I recalled the number of useful instructional YouTube videos I’ve seen, especially those that predate the well-produced, well-articulated “DadTube” era.

There was a period of years when older men, unpracticed at speaking for the camera, were an invaluable source of democratizing how-to knowledge.

fuussssip |root |parent |previous [-]

It definitely is an insult. A typically very mild one, but it's definitely an insult.

koutakun |root |parent |previous [-]

No link to his channel or video either. Of course, the author probably thinks the mechanic is lesser because he went into the trades and helps people not have to buy new electronics every 6 months, instead of going into a Higher Industry™ like child-killing drone software.

I swear tradespeople have to stop sharing their tricks with us for a decade at least.

njovin |next |previous [-]

I've had similar issues with an LG clothes washer (solenoid) and a clothes dryer (worn bearing), both ~10 years old.

Both issues required a <$50 part, a solid youtube video from a knowledgeable repairman, and about 2 hours worth of manual labor on my part. Neither was technically challenging nor required anything beyond a few screwdrivers.

People sometimes overestimate how complex these non-smart appliances are and how readily available the parts are.

The guys putting these videos up on youtube and keeping them there are the real heroes.

dunham |next |previous [-]

I had an issue with my Bosch dishwasher a few years ago (last minute took forever). The internet told me it was a common problem with that model and a pin on a relay in the controller needed to be re-soldered. Fixed it without having to pull it out of the cabinet. I suspect a repairman would have replaced the entire controller and, with labor, charge the price of a new dishwasher.

My samsung fridge is in a holding pattern. It collects a little water and ice in the bottom of the fridge section. It's old enough that the plastic is getting brittle (drawers, etc), so not worth repairing (and all of the repair people I've talked to for other issues say they won't touch samsung fridges). So I shop vac it every other week.

tonyedgecombe |root |parent [-]

>It collects a little water and ice in the bottom of the fridge section.

There is often a drain hole somewhere near the bottom that can get blocked. It might just need cleaning out with a pipe cleaner.

9x39 |next |previous [-]

My fridge had stopped working. It was warm inside. 10 years old. Crap. Bought a nice new fridge at the orange store on a great deal.

My buddy reminded me sometimes it's just a little part that goes out, and to try youtube for a repair video. Turns out, my LG fridge often has a fan go out that blows freezer air into the fridge - that's how that model works. Sure enough, the freezer _is_ fine. $20 later on Amazon, I have the fan, and in 30 minutes we have it replaced. Another 30 minutes later, and we're cold again. 3 years later, it's still going strong as our garage fridge.

It occurs to me we get conditioned sometimes to not even attempting repairs, although to be fair, some tech repairs are hopeless, but it's not _all_ hopeless.

js2 |root |parent [-]

That's how every fridge/freezer combo I'm aware of works. A fan circulates air over the evaporator coil in the freezer compartment both within freezer and up into the fridge compartment. It's not uncommon for the fan to break. There's also a small door in the fridge compartment (called a damper) that controls the amount of air allowed in to the fridge compartment. The motor that controls that can also sometimes get stuck. I've been in my home since 2004 and we're on our second fridge/freezer. The compressor failed on the first one after about 12 years, but not before I had replaced the evaporator fan motor.

Still on the original dish washer and double-oven. Had to replace the top-loading washer about 10 years ago, decided to replace the dryer then too in order to switch from gas to electric. Second microwave. Got tired of replacing the damn door micro switches on the first one.

Home appliances are pretty basic to work on. As long as you can find the parts. The hardest part of working on the double-oven (needed new elements) was building an exact height dolly so I could slide it out of the cabinet on my own:

https://ibb.co/v3RzLND

https://ibb.co/5Lxqc3N

lubujackson |next |previous [-]

We have repaired both our washer and dryer several times over the past 15 years since we bought them - YT makes this easy nowadays. I am far from handy but I can follow clear instructions and it seems newer models have only gotten more brittle and have shit like internet connectivity, which I do not want nor need. I would much rather they use 50 cents more for key metallic parts instead of shoddy plastic.

ErroneousBosh |root |parent [-]

Our house has a late-80s dishwasher that works well, is really quiet, and not really any less energy-efficient than a modern one.

However, its door hinges have broken a couple of times. It never really shut right, and on getting the door apart I discovered that the hinges are a pair of pressed steel "legs" with a fork in the end and an attachment for the counterbalance spring.

Unavailable for years, cracked right in half, bent as a banana.

But, mild steel. So easy to grind the crack out, hammer it flat, and weld a reinforcing plate across the inside, and build the outside up with weld and grind flat.

When I say I'm a "full stack" engineer, I mean I can bring a JTAG cable and assembler along, or I can bring a MIG welder, and sometimes both at the same time.

comrade1234 |next |previous [-]

I have property in a rural part of the USA where I have to do a lot for myself because there aren't competent people to do it, or if there are they have to bill for 2+ hours of travel as they're far away.

Where I live in Europe I'd rather pay a professional to do the work.

pornel |next |previous [-]

Please put units on temperature values. Outside US this sounds like a story about fridge getting half way to boiling its contents.

articulatepang |root |parent |next [-]

A perfect time for Bayesian inference!

If someone is shocked to find their fridge above 50 degrees but relieved to find it humming at 32, what's your posterior probability distribution on the units? Even if your prior says something like 95% of humans on the planet use Celsius units, the update is pretty strong, right?

Don't forget to consider the _hundreds_ of people who work primarily in Kelvin, like the statistical physicists and quantum mechanics.

(I think you should also update based on English text on the internet. The 95% figure is for humans on the planet. The US has 2/3 of the world's native English speakers, but only something like 25% of people who might plausibly use English on the internet. I'm counting India, Europe, Nigeria, the Philippines, and Pakistan as likely to use English online.)

CyLith |root |parent |previous [-]

Then I guess you figured out the units pretty easily.

anthonyIPH |next |previous [-]

I had a fridge die the same way,the coils were so caked in cat hair and dust that the inverter needed to be replaced. I'd love a household appliance required maintenance cheat sheet, so I can avoid learning other lessons the hard way.

Also, milk delivery is still a thing?

ErroneousBosh |root |parent |next [-]

We get our milk delivered from a dairy a few miles away. Annoyingly when we started getting it, it was from a dairy a ten minute walk from my house, but the guy that ran it retired and sold up to a larger one.

The milk still comes from local herds and is bottled on site.

This is is rural NE Scotland, where you can get just about any meat, root veg, or brassica so fresh you're practically picking it up out of the field. Actually if you go "tattie roving" - gleaning the ground after the potato harvest, which a lot of people do, you are literally picking it up out of the field.

Now if I could reliably get tea and coffee bushes, cumin, and ginger to grow reliably, my food miles could be covered with a walk up the garden at best and half an hour in the car at worst.

0xbadcafebee |root |parent |previous [-]

[dead]

incognito124 |next |previous [-]

In a similar story, I had ice build up in the external A/C unit. I only noticed because it started falling off directly below where the neighbour parked his car, and added a few stripes on the hood :)

Long story short, it was the dust in the internal unit. Cleaning it thoroughly and leaving it to dry for one hot, European summer day, solved it. Bonkers.

ninalanyon |next |previous [-]

The fridge was at 50 F/10 C and you didn't notice it was too warm until the milk was spoilt?

ikidd |next |previous [-]

An International Harvester fridge.

First I've ever heard that IH made appliances and not just machinery. Very interesting.

hapless |root |parent [-]

Most of the American carmakers dabbled in appliances

Frigidaire was a General Motors brand. Philco was a Ford brand. Chrysler made home A/Cs for many years. Nash famously merged with Kelvinator.

tonymet |next |previous [-]

A multimeter has saved me over $10k on hvac, automotive, electronics and general DIY repairs around the house. Everyone should have one because technicians aren’t fully honest. And they are a great safety tool for household electrical.

I recommend putting thermometers in your fridge, and also make sure your fridge is ventilating properly. It needs ample clearance and annual cleaning. If you haven’t cleaned you can do so. Or put your fridge on a kill-a-watt and ask AI to compare your cycle times to the Energy Star listing. if your fridge is running a lot longer than it should, it will likely fail

hagbard_c |next |previous [-]

I repair everything at home, from tractors via cars through washing machines, dishwashers, microwave (just replaced the magnetron in one, yes it can be done without executing yourself just as long as you discharge the capacitor), televisions, computers, the farm house, the barn, etc. I'm not an expert in anything but a generalist in everything which tends to be enough for this type of work. I built our water system, the sewer system, installed the solar panels and inverter, installed all electricity including the fuse boxes, built the chimney, currently building a wood-fired central heating system with heat storage tanks, etcetera. What it takes to do this is a combination of can-do with enough common sense to avoid accidents. Read up before you start, know your limits but don't be scared by all the naysayers who insist on leaving everything to the 'experts' either. They probably don't know which side of a soldering iron to hold and as such are not the ones to use for guidance. Yes, electricity can be dangerous, so can carbon monoxide, diesel and petrol, heavy things like trees, ladders, etc. Read up, maybe watch a few videos if that's your thing and get repairing/building. Before you know it you'll be self-reliant in one or more areas where you previously had to rely on the 'experts' who often turn out to be guessing and billing their way towards solutions.

cucumber3732842 |root |parent [-]

Careful, that shit snowballs fast.

You're a teenager doing your first brake job meticulously following the service literature, you blink, and you're 45, you've got a semi trailer precariously propped up on random shit in your residential back yard while you torch the axles off with one hand and use the garden hose to put the ground fires out with the other because you needed a garden shed and it was free.

hagbard_c |root |parent [-]

No semi-trailer yet even though I have plenty of space for one. For the rest, yes, being able to repair broken things means you can end up with a lot of things. Give them away sometimes, it helps and makes people glad, there's websites where you can offload earlier projects (and find new ones). Knowing that you can repair most broken things can turn problems into annoyances, from "the car won't start and I have to get to work tomorrow, what now" to "stupid ass car, why did you throw up this #%)#¤"&("#¤% error in the ECU which tells me I need to cut the last 5 cm of that vacuum hose 'cause it leaks" or "The guests are coming in 4 hours and now the oven's not turning on" to "yep, that spade connector has had it, better replace it so the cake will be ready before the guests come". It takes time and effort but that tends to be time otherwise spent watching brain-rot television and the effort is off-set with the satisfaction of knowing a job well-done.

You might end up like me, accumulating far (far) more viewing time on the back side of televisions than on the front. Count yourself lucky, the programming tends to be much more interesting.

|next |previous [-]

SV_BubbleTime |next |previous [-]

Am I missing something?

“I thought our fridge was going bad, I replaced a part and it seems to have worked”

Is this worthy of a blog entry and hackernews? I think many adults end up doing this every couples months.

schoen |root |parent |next [-]

Maybe a lot of people here are comparatively pure software people and are surprised, impressed, and grateful when they successfully do technical stuff in the physical world!

When I was a kid, I was already a computer nerd and writing my own programs, yet I had a friend from school who manually replaced his PC speaker (I forgot why, but he did this) that was wired rather than jumped to the motherboard. I was super-impressed, as this felt like a completely out-of-context kind of action to me, like, you can actually physically modify or replace components in your computer!?

Taking a basic bike maintenance class as an adult cyclist was also pretty amazing to me, as there were some actions that seemed mysterious and magical to me that got somewhat demystified (on a machine that I had used every day for years).

I also gave a talk at one point about how side-channel attacks based on physical properties of computers are often so surprising and counterintuitive for software people (including myself) because we so rarely think about how computers are physically instantiated and how that physical instantiation may leak various sensitive information. (In practice, it often does, if you can look at it appropriately.)

I think some people gravitated to software because we love the abstraction and power of "this is an abstract machine" (we don't get to play with formal systems that work automatically in other areas of life). "Wow, it follows arbitrary sequences of formal instructions perfectly!" The refrigerator in the anecdote is, well, not an abstract machine.

As other people in the thread have said, there are places and times where more familiarity with the physical world and physical details of machinery would probably be a lot more routine and less surprising.

wowczarek |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Exactly.

Reaching for a repairman (or worse, replacing the thing) is in many backgrounds and countries still a modern luxury. Instilling the idea that things like this are left to "true" professionals is the goal of decades-long commercial conditioning of now generations of humans. So yes, no wonder that someone sees this as amazing - I see this as simply what one does; fixing things.

My mum knew how to do a quick fan belt or radiator fix in the middle of nowhere when the car broke down, and I wouldn't call her a hacker for that, and it really was nothing special, in the context of how widely people fixed things like that.

And then people don't know how to sew on a proverbial button, so, yeah.

xyzzy123 |root |parent |next [-]

There's a lot going on though. I'd say we went through a few phases.

Old stuff was less reliable / had more consumables (belts, bearings, ...), but when parts broke it was often straightforward to replace them. So you got practice and reinforcement. There was also a pretty large pool of generalists who could fix anything.

Then there was a long period where manufacturing was pretty good but also calling in a repair was fairly cheap. Things did get a bit more specialised. The system complexity was not as high as today, e.g. in the 80s up to early 90s board level repair in the field even without schematics was routine.

New stuff is generally designed to be cheap to manufacture at the cost of repairability; often the "consumables" are not wear parts like belts, brushes, bearings but stuff like latches, buttons or boards that are expensive because they have to be warehoused for 10 years and have an extremely specific use. System complexity is much higher, with specialist chips, firmware and sensors, model-specific injection moulded parts, etc.

At the same time Baumol means that actually getting someone to come to your house now tends to cost $100 before they do anything and regardless of what they know.

Again from Baumol, the economic value of the average person's time has gone up relative to the cost of appliances (i.e it hurts less to just buy a new one) and we also own more appliances.

I guess what I'm saying is that I feel that broad economic factors are what make the repair ecosystem look like it does today, rather than mustache twirling villains or helpless consumers (even if the last two things are factors sometimes).

wolfi1 |root |parent |previous [-]

my country subsidizes repairmen to a certain extent, the reason behind this is to reduce the amount of appliances going to the landfill

jetrink |root |parent |next |previous [-]

In the United States, I would guess the percentage of adults who have repaired a household appliance is 10-25%. Most people just replace appliances when they break. I believe that most people could accomplish a repair like the one in the post, but most don't have the tools or the confidence.

tgsovlerkhgsel |root |parent [-]

I would expect the percentage of adults under 40 that have ever done so to be well below 10%. Probably closer to 1%.

zulux |root |parent |next |previous [-]

No. But yes, in my opinion.

Encouraging each other to become independent is a good thing, even if it's boring for some of us.

mung |root |parent |previous [-]

I thought it was a reference to internet-connected freezers destroying frozen goods around Europe.

Except kind of... "I think there is a joke here somewhere... Im just not sure how to complete it."

15o9o |next |previous [-]

true hacker!

snvzz |next |previous [-]

Not stopped by some sort of DRM? Amazing.

comrade1234 |previous [-]

Do adults drink milk?

TheSamFischer |root |parent |next [-]

Yes, it’s delicious.

IncreasePosts |root |parent |next |previous [-]

In america and Europe where adult lactose intolerance isn't common, yes. Not universally but a lot do.

Anonbrit |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Yes

emmelaich |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Apparently the Romans didn't drink milk. And they found it disgusting that the Picts/Britons did.

zarzavat |root |parent [-]

They had a point. I'm not sure that I'd want to drink unrefrigerated raw milk either anymore.

Henchman21 |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Perhaps not in Soviet Russia, Comrade1234