Hacker News
How the Telephone Changed the World
tialaramex
|next
[-]
The thing these have in common is that they're connecting all the people. There is no intermediary necessary. Probably you won't send a postcard to some child you've never met in Shanghai, make a phone call to a random farmer in Ukraine or use a video chat to call random Venezuelans on the Internet, but you can and that's why these networks are so powerful.
NooneAtAll5
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
EarlKing
|root
|parent
|next
|previous
[-]
tialaramex
|root
|parent
[-]
If the UPU begins a thousand years earlier that falls by the same reasoning, a thousand years earlier too many people aren't literate, so they need to have their letter written by someone else, and the recipient must find someone to read it - but by the time of the UPU literacy is widespread.
gbcfghhjj
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
The telegraph is the most impactful of all the telecommunication inventions because it is the one that moved communication from days to transport a physical message to the other side of the world to near instantaneous.
tialaramex
|root
|parent
[-]
The Public Switched Telephone Network does not "require an operator to complete calls". Strowger's original machine is a bit fiddly but the dial telephone with its pulsed signalling and the switches developed from Strowger's ideas dominated for much of the 20th century.
If you only have the Telephone then yeah, initially you need to hope the other end is listening and make a noise to get their attention - ringing telephone bells happen later, but that, I argue, is not the Network. Sending a bloke on a horse with your message is also not the Network.
userbinator
|root
|parent
[-]
The operators were the switches.
limagnolia
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
tialaramex
|root
|parent
[-]
For purely pragmatic reasons tampering with mail was never common, Comstock and the Trump attempt both try to co-opt a large Federal institution to do something everybody hates which is part of why they both failed. It's extra work to snoop through all those boring letters to see whether anybody said things you wish they wouldn't, "Ain't nobody got time for that" as someone once said.
dsign
|next
|previous
[-]
The pocket-destroying cellphone I have from my company (which I must carry at all times, because of on-call) comes with spyware, it also comes with a two-factor authentication app that flashes an angry error message because I don't allow notifications. I'm of course exaggerating a little and speaking subjectively, but that phone feels more like a slave collar than something I really want to have around, and the feeling hasn't subsided one bit in the five years I've carried it.
Even with my personal phone (an iphone), things are not much better. It sends who-knows-what-of-my-data to god-knows-where, and of course keeping the radios active for all that chitchat costs battery time. It doesn't allow me to run any custom-made app I may need without paying Apple a hefty developer subscription and getting a Mac. And, ultimately, it's Apple's device, with security functions to protect Apple and to guarantee other companies with apps running in the phone that the device won't really let me if I try to, say, break their DRM.
userbinator
|root
|parent
[-]
nikanj
|root
|parent
[-]
apublicfrog
|root
|parent
[-]
devilbunny
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
This is why non-individual phones are still so common in businesses. You usually just need to talk to someone, who can route your call as needed. You might not even know who it is you need to talk to - e.g., in a hospital, you need to talk to whoever is covering X right now, without needing to know the entire schedule of everyone in the place.
tacostakohashi
|next
|previous
[-]
There were phone lines to get movie times, the time, automated phone banking to get your balance and make transfers, buying things on the phone like 1-800-flowers, dial-a-pizza, taxis, qvc / "home shopping" channels, phone sex lines, all that stuff. It was peak phone. Also, people had cordless phones, speaker phones, answering machines, all sorts of accessories, and generally cared about their phone.
Then, in the late 90s/2000s, all that stuff shifted to the web. In the 2010s... it all shifted to apps / smartphones. Now... it's all shifting to AI / agentic.
The delivery medium keeps changing and cannibalizing the previous one, but the actual stuff being delivered stays kind of the same.
apublicfrog
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
I've already started dry running this as an experiment. It is alarming how many companies, government systems etc are not possible to use without a smart phone with internet, a camera (computer one won't suffice), SMS capability, access to Google or Apple's stores or sometimes all of the above.
paulorlando
|next
|previous
[-]
bonoboTP
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
kiscica
|root
|parent
[-]
(Also, I remember that, in the 80s and early 90s at least, the wait to get a phone installed was much shorter in many smaller towns and villages than it was in Budapest. The same sort of thing happened later with the advent of broadband. As I recall, I had 100Mbps service in a small village in the south of Hungary before it was available in Budapest - and I could only get 20Mbps at the time in the USA!)
LurkandComment
|next
|previous
[-]
smelendez
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
The new Gleick book this piece is excerpted from gets the most into the technical aspects, which makes sense given Gleick’s background. There’s also a lot about the patent disputes in the early days of the phone and its impact in its early days on popular culture.
I think there’s still more phone history to be written. I’d like to see a social history of the phone in the period basically from WW II to the iPhone, including unexpected and deviant use of the phone: phone phreaking, prank calls, music over the phone, sex lines, collect calling, right wing voice message lines, phone zap protests, telemarketing, and I’m sure things I don’t even know about. Plus how the rise of technology like cordless phones, extension lines, etc. delivered privacy for phone users in their own homes.
anigbrowl
|next
|previous
[-]
xnx
|next
|previous
[-]
Telegraph seems like the more significant milestone, but putting that in the title of a book wouldn't sell many copies.
smelendez
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
Which, after all, is why people want to read about it. Most people don’t have much firsthand experience with the telegraph.
z3c0
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
userbinator
|next
|previous
[-]
But in the next century the knowledge would be lost again
The number of young people I've seen not knowing how to hold a phone increased significantly the past few years; I've seen them holding smartphones with the screen up, and using them as half-duplex, alternating between the mic end in front of their mouth and the speaker end pointing towards an ear. For someone holding a phone in the customary full-duplex manner, this makes for a very annoying conversation with awkward pauses and missed words.
mikestew
|next
|previous
[-]
“How the Telephone Changed the World”
(Though in this rare instance the the title still makes some sense.)