Hacker News

The First Revolver: How We Got from Blackbeard's Six Pistols to the Six-Shooter

64 points by bushwart ago | 49 comments

Animats |next [-]

Until Colt's revolver after 1830, few of those weapons were suitable for routine carry. When you were going off to fight, you got your weapon ready, which with flintlocks involved putting in fresh powder. Early pistols didn't stay safely ready for use. So pistols were offensive weapons.

Concealed carry, the early years: For loading a Philadelphia Deringer, one would typically fire a couple of percussion caps on the handgun, to dry out any residual moisture contained in the tube or at the base of the barrel, to prevent a subsequent misfire. One would then remove the remains of the last fired percussion cap and place the handgun on its half-cock notch, pour 15 to 25 grains (0.97 to 1.6 g) of black powder down the barrel, followed by ramming a patched lead ball down onto the powder, being very careful to leave no air gap between the patched ball and the powder, to prevent the handgun from exploding when used. ... A new percussion cap would then be placed on the tube (nipple), and the gun was then loaded and ready to fire.[1]

Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derringer

AngryData |root |parent |next [-]

But at the same time the people who wrote the constitution knew full well repeating firearms were coming at some point and didn't think it made enough difference to change anything or note anything about it. They saw and were offered to buy such firearms both for personal and military use and had personally saw many other firearm improvements and reduction in costs throughout their life.

phoghed |root |parent |next [-]

These guys left no shortage of written material, probably best to just pull up their actual thoughts on the topic rather than two sides of the argument just pulling shit out of their ass and throwing it at each other

jghn |root |parent |previous [-]

I'm gonna go out on on a limb and suggest they weren't picturing anything like modern weaponry. And that if someone were to smuggle a minigun through a Time Machine, they'd think it was witchcraft

ggreer |root |parent |next [-]

The founding fathers couldn't have imagined anything like modern digital communication, but it's hard to find people claiming that the 1st amendment only applies to the printing press and hand-written letters. If the 1st amendment applies to e-mail & websites, and the 4th amendment applies to data, then the 2nd amendment applies to modern rifles & handguns. If that's a problem, then the solution is to amend the constitution.

ThrowawayR2 |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Multibarrel volley guns (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volley_gun) and the rotating cylinder Puckle gun (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puckle_gun) had already been developed before the American Revolution so the concept of repeating firearms would not have been alien. The mystery about the minigun would be how the extreme precision of the machining was accomplished, not the mechanism by which it operated or the cartridges.

Well, there's also the electric motor and that a metal more expensive than gold at the time, aluminum, was used for some components but that's not related to the mechanics of the firearm itself.

ahazred8ta |root |parent [-]

The 1597 Hans Stopler revolver had 8 cylinders. There were revolvers in the 1600s and 1700s.

Also: 'the right to keep and bear arms' also includes swords. The 2nd A does not say firearms.

AngryData |root |parent |next |previous [-]

They lived in a time of technological and mechanical revolution themselves so I don't see them finding a revolver unfathomable. They were alive when the Jaquet-Droz automata was made and all sorts of mechanical marvels were coming into existance. A better repeating firearm to them would be like telling you that in 50 years cars can autonomously drive in any conditions as good or better than a human.

Animats |root |parent [-]

There were some very clever one-off or small volume designs in the history of firearms, but common handguns were unreliable, unsafe, and high-maintenance before Colt.

arcanemachiner |root |parent |next |previous [-]

I'm gonna go out on a limb and suggest they wanted people to overthrow their government if it became tyrannical.

asdff |root |parent |next [-]

I'm not sure how much that line is even really serious vs just a sort of way to ensure the country were sufficiently armed against reconquest by the British, with a very weak central government and hardly any ability to levy actual armies. In this way they'd make use of emotional feelings of patriotism and mandate of the people to just have the farmers and small folk behave somewhat irrationally, paying for the state's military expenditure directly out of their own wages, vs some tax structure that might actually impact real property wealth of which many of the founding fathers had substantial holdings. Especially when the role of the military is really to protect property rights vs some general protection of the people (e.g. the british and american revolutionaries had no fight with the poor folk who would be tilling fields in either way, it was really all about tax rates on large property holdings and business functionally, sold as a moment of liberation to drum the small folk into risking their lives and livelihoods). I mean really, ask yourself if you really have representation over your taxation today, or if it is controlled more by forces where you and your opinions are an irrelevant factor.

When you think it two steps ahead it really just makes no sense. So people are supposedly allowed to rise up against tyrannical government, but then what about John Brown, or the civil war for that matter? By this logic, the existing US government is tyrannical if they are actually squaring up to fight a citizen who has determined it is time to take up arms against what they perceive as a tyrranical government. The act of the government actually being baited into playing ball on this turns it into a tyrannical government by definition: here it is shooting and killing other American citizens who hold a political grievance. To say nothing on the positions of the civil war but to see it for what it is: a political debate that has gone hot.

Then you have to wonder especially with the military after the civil war, with more reorganization away from the local militia model, how would the government have behaved towards a group of citizens who are stockpiling up arms? I'm not sure they would have allowed joe shmoe from down the block in 1920 to have a basement full of tommy guns and dynamite either.

jghn |root |parent |previous [-]

They did indeed. So why is it not the case that every citizen is allowed to have a ballistic missile armed with a MIRV warhead?

AngryData |root |parent [-]

Why not indeed? Politicians might be a lot more honest if we did.

Avicebron |root |parent [-]

Neighbourhood nuclear superiority is the one trick HOAs can't stand!

bryanrasmussen |root |parent |next |previous [-]

well, I'm gonna go out on a limb and suggest the most well known signatories to the Constitution would not have thought it was witchcraft, there may be some backward fellow in their ranks that might be so inclined, but as a general rule no, you're off by a few hundred years.

jghn |root |parent [-]

Maybe don't interpret every word 100% literally, as not everything is meant that way. Not unlike how it's silly to try to interpret the constitution literally with a contemporary viewpoint.

phoghed |root |parent [-]

HN discourse falling from the steel man to the jello man, hate to see it.

cucumber3732842 |root |parent |previous [-]

IDK what the exact modern equivalent of "you and your buddies get a cannon and let fly at the state police" is but that's basically the sort of war they just finished fighting so I bet they'd be fine with personally owned Javelins and AT4s on the basis that SWAT has APCs and the citizenry needs the hardware to counter that if they get too big for their britches.

wingspar |root |parent |next |previous [-]

The term BEAR is right in the text of the amendment.

cucumber3732842 |root |parent |next |previous [-]

>Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.

If your goal is a legal basis gun control then "handguns sucked then" is a stupid argument because the obvious counter is "ok, well random dudes could just buy the kit that let them go toe to toe with professional infantry so why don't you give us that and we'll call it even" and that's probably way worse for whatever the next thing you want after you get your gun control is.

ultimafan |root |parent [-]

Not just toe to toe with infantry- I'm fairly certain civilians could own and operate warships outfitted with cannons (if they could afford them) too. In that sense 2A is completely neutered- imagine a modern civilian amassing enough power to go toe to toe with a modern Navy today!

ericmay |root |parent |next |previous [-]

> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak. Handgun technology wasn't ready in 1789.

People routinely carried and possessed other guns though so I'm not sure that's a good argument. At best you are arguing against concealed carry but there is no constitutional amendment addressing concealed carry.

If you want to argue that the 2nd Amendment only talks about what would mostly be considered a professional or semi-professional military then you have to revert back to 10th Amendment since the 2nd Amendment doesn't ban citizens from owning firearms it just grants the right to have a militia, ergo each state unless another constitutional amendment happens at the federal level can set forth (or not if they don't want to regulate it) the right for individual citizens to own firearms. The worst case is you get some states banning it, and other states having a lot more lax laws, something more akin to the roll back of Roe V Wade. Anti-gun rights activists should be careful that they don't disrupt the status quo less they find even fewer restrictions, as anti-abortion activists discovered when states began enshrining the right to an abortion in their own state constitutions.

It doesn't matter anyway because we as a society for good reasons decided that we wanted folks to be able to carry a handgun concealed or to otherwise own and carry firearms. That's all we really need - we just say we want to do something and then we get to do it.

Forgeties79 |root |parent [-]

While I disagree with a lot of your argument I think a lot of it has merit. This part though I’m stuck on

> as anti-abortion activists discovered when states began enshrining the right to an abortion in their own state constitutions.

I’m not sure I see the through line between states enshrining a woman’s right to choose and the overturning of Roe v. Wade. That was a half century project that was plowing ahead no matter what. I think states putting their own protections in place was very prudent

ericmay |root |parent [-]

The way I was attempting to link it was that there could be a similar and (according to anti-abortion activists) in some ways disastrous result where they basically said well it's not up to the federal government, and so (much to my happiness) many states went ahead and said oh it's up to us? Fine we're going to put it to a public vote and allow access and put that in the Constitution. And oh by the way, we may make it even less restrictive than it was under Roe V Wade.

Similarly my point was that if anti-gun activists were to in some way succeed in having the 2nd Amendment interpreted as (and I understand their argument though I disagree with the results) only applying to a militia, you'd probably wind up in a similar situation where states go and put it up to a vote and then they allow for firearms in each state constitution (not all of course) and they may even expand that right. Because hey, 10th Amendment. If it's not a power given to the federal government it is given to the states.

In other words, Roe v Wade and the current interpretation of the 2nd Amendment aren't perfect and there are problems to be solved, but you might let the cat out of the bag so to speak like the anti-abortion activists discovered and wind up with a worse situation than you started with (from those various perspectives) because it seems quite clear to me, and of course I'm just a random person, that there is no constitutional amendment banning firearms so by default excluding any sort of trigger laws (no pun intended) you'd all of a sudden have guns completely legal everywhere and without restriction until constitutional amendments later on restricted them. There could be some roughness around the edges like, bringing a gun to a bar and drinking or something, but just more broadly I could see that play out. So it's a be careful what you wish for scenario, in my view.

saila |root |parent [-]

The vast majority of states already have a right to bear arms written into their state constitutions. Many of them are much clearer than the 2nd Amendment. Take Oregon's, for example:

> The people shall have the right to bear arms for the defence of themselves, and the State, but the Military shall be kept in strict subordination to the civil power.

No arguments about a well-regulated militia to be had there.

If the 2nd Amendment was reinterpreted to apply only to militias, the state constitutions and their laws would still be applicable as would federal law, given that there's nothing else in the Constitution about it one way or the other.

ericmay |root |parent [-]

That’s my point - sorry if I didn’t make that clear. Similarly when Roe V Wade was struck down trigger laws and constitutional amendments at the state level became law.

So with respect to concealed carry, going back to the OP, it doesn’t really matter whether or not handguns were “ready” in 1789. Further the 2nd Amendment itself probably doesn’t matter because if it were to be reinterpreted you’d have to then revert to individual state constitutions which in many (most?) cases allow for civilians to own firearms and thus can also decide whether concealed carry is ok or not.

TacticalCoder |root |parent |previous [-]

> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak.

So the 4th amendment that says this:

"... secure in their persons, houses, papers, ..."

doesn't concern digital information because the notion of information stored digitally and not in paper wasn't envisioned by the Constitution?

cucumber3732842 |root |parent |next [-]

We're in this weird legal hangover because the greatest generation through boomers never saw a power they didn't think the .gov should have and contorted everything to that end but I expect that in the next 20-40yr we'll have precedents that unwind those boondoggles and get our digital stuff protected the same way that bank and telecom stuff is.

delichon |root |parent |previous [-]

Same for the 1st amendment in modern times. Try this version: "Historical arguments for free online speech from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak."

brudgers |next |previous [-]

At irregular intervals ranging from twice in a row to more than a decade, I've been rereading Blood Meridian since the 90's.

At some point more toward the present than the beginning, I started thinking about it as a story about the impact of a technology -- seeing it as a story about the revolver allowing a new scale of human violence.

Don't get me wrong, I have other readings alongside that one.

tomjakubowski |root |parent |next [-]

I read it for the first time last year (see my HN bio) and had similar thoughts. Judge Holden, in his insatiable and devouring hunger for information, is like a frontier LLM. Take the scene where he makes the neat, careful impression of the rare plant's leaf in his journal, before he annihilates it. The judge seeks to consume everything in the natural world and leave only his own recording of it behind.

brudgers |root |parent |next [-]

One of my other readings of Blood Meridian is that The Judge is Cormac McCarthy turning his editing into part of the narrative.

The baby is the kind of thing this reading explains: he introduced the baby as a story line and edited it out later with the Judge killing the baby right after its introduction.

At a higher level, the Judge's seeming omniscience is what an author has (as well as determining life and death of the characters).

jonah-archive |root |parent |previous [-]

my (second) favorite passage from the book:

----

Whatever exists, he said. Whatever in creation exists without my knowledge exists without my consent.

He looked about at the dark forest in which they were bivouacked. He nodded toward the specimens he'd collected. These anonymous creatures, he said, may seem little or nothing in the world. Yet the smallest crumb can devour us. Any smallest thing beneath yon rock out of men's knowing. Only nature can enslave man and only when the existence of each last entity is routed out and made to stand naked before him will he be properly suzerain of the earth.

----

engineer_22 |root |parent |previous [-]

just wait till you hear about Genghis Kahn

sharkjacobs |root |parent [-]

That's actually a pretty good comparison, composite bows and horse archery are similarly devastating technologies brought to bear on an unprepared populace.

I wonder, is Genghis Khan Glanton in this analogy or The Judge

brudgers |root |parent |next [-]

The characters in Blood Meridian aren't building a political entity or trying to control land or perpetuate blood lines. They are simply collecting scalps for money from a government willing to pay them.

Illniyar |root |parent |previous [-]

Unprepared? Practically everyone the mongols conquered fought steepe nomads for centuries before.

Whatever advantages mongols had was not in the novelty of horse archery.

Starman_Jones |root |parent [-]

Kinda wild to think that for literally all of recorded history, one of these two (unrelated) things was true: Americans were worried about their government coming for their guns OR The steppe people were being a menace with horse archers.

Merrill |next |previous [-]

"God created men; Samuel Colt made them equal." - Traditional adage.

Glyptodon |next |previous [-]

I remember going to a museum in Switzerland with some really weird proto revolvers, like inner and outer rings with different barrel arrangements. Can't find pictures or remember exactly how they worked, but pretty sure they were pre 1800 and not very practical.

k0morebi |next |previous [-]

Highly recommend "Forgotten Weapons" on YouTube. I know he has one on the puckle gun, not sure about the others. But he gets some pretty nice exclusive access to historical pieces from around the world and often gets to disassemble them. Incredible level of engineering ingenuity and metal working that went into firearms hundreds of years ago.

kleton |next |previous [-]

nominative determinism

> In June 1818, Artemus Wheeler of Concord, Massachusetts, received a U.S. patent for a flintlock revolver.

Molitor5901 |next |previous [-]

This is such a great article, comma. I had never really understood the pepperbox until now. I thought it fired all of the projectiles at one time. I didn't know you rotated.

unpleasurable |root |parent |next [-]

The long 7-barrelled Nock Gun (1779) did: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nock_gun

ksd482 |root |parent |previous [-]

Did you use voice to text for posting this comment?

What's with ", comma" ?

Did you mean to write "This is such a great article, I had never really understood the pepperbox until now." instead?

arcanemachiner |root |parent [-]

I think it's a safe bet to assume they used speech to text to dictate that comment, as I just did for mine.

christkv |next |previous [-]

I got to shot a Colt Walker reproduction gun a decade ago and it was heavy and had quite the kick no exactly made for precision shooting. More like a hand canon.

mythrwy |previous [-]

You can buy replica black powder revolvers (in the US anyway). They are not expensive and very fun to shoot. They are almost like a small cannon in sound and feel and a huge cloud of smoke comes out. They get very dirty though even with modern "smokeless" powders (which still make a lot more smoke than a conventional firearm).

There are a lot less legal restrictions on these in the US. I ordered one online 20 years ago or so. No background checks, no ID and they delivered it in the mail and dropped the package off with my neighbor.

It's a fairly serious weapon. .44 caliber with 6 shots (but then it takes a few minutes to reload). I've never been very accurate with it however, not sure if it's me or the weapon.