Hacker News
New Mexico wanted free childcare for all; what's worked – and what hasn't
thephyber
|next
[-]
Seems like a reasonable way to handle it. Not like a family can find childcare for $150/month anyway, so even if wealthy families pay a copay, everybody comes out ahead. Or should, once the day care supply issues are addressed.
georgemcbay
|next
|previous
[-]
They don't need it, but IMO means testing is generally a huge waste of time and money, creates unfortunate "benefit cliffs" and just creates political division instead of broad universal support.
Make all such benefits universal but also progressively tax wealthy people fairly and it all works itself out.
thephyber
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
Reagan famously made the "Welfare Queen" a political meme and now most people from at least one political party have that caricature emblazoned on their brain, even if it was closer to the Mandela Effect than truth.
Grombobulous
|root
|parent
|next
|previous
[-]
Nobody suggests that the upper middle class and above start paying extra to use a sidewalk or a sewer but then as soon as other categories of government service come up all of a sudden making society more equitable isn’t fair.
And you’re right about benefit cliffs and the bureaucratic burden of qualification. I think this is a big part of what UBI advocates are trying to say: you can spend money for benefits administrators to make sure there’s no fraud in the system which ends up adding cost and inefficiency when it might be better to just hand out the money to whoever signs up.
readthenotes1
|root
|parent
[-]
I could be snarky and say that rich people don't use sidewalks:)
ZeroGravitas
|root
|parent
|next
[-]
This has the added benefit of moving what are already essentially taxes off electricity bills lowering per unit cost which encourages electrification of fossil fuel use cases.
eesmith
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
People aren't charged more for checking out more books. Which is a good thing for me since as a kid I would check out 20+ books at a time, and my family didn't have money.
That snark will backfire. It exactly why rich people say they shouldn't have to pay taxes for things they never use, like sidewalks and public libraries.
solyin
|root
|parent
[-]
eesmith
|root
|parent
[-]
"I shouldn’t have to pay school district tax if I have no children" - https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueUnpopularOpinion/comments/14pj2...
with top response "This selfish opinion is surprisingly popular."
"With no kids in school, I shouldn’t have to pay full taxes " - https://altamontenterprise.com/10022019/no-kids-school-i-sho...
"Why do property taxes fund schools when only a subset of residents actually use said schools?" - https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/73439/why-do-pr...
There's lots more. See https://noai.duckduckgo.com/?q=don%27t+have+kids+shouldn%27t... .
compsciphd
|root
|parent
[-]
A different way to align the values would be to allow families to deduct private school tuition up to the average amount (or perhaps based on education type, as special needs students cost more) from their income for tax purposes. In this type of world, said private school sending family wouldn't be so upset if the local district paid more per kid. They also wouldn't be able to deduct more than their localized amount.
This doesn't quite respond to the above about "no kids", but it is an area of conflict in areas with relatively large private school populations with also a public school population.
Grombobulous
|root
|parent
|next
|previous
[-]
I also question why the state needs to cater to most private school demographics. The state shouldn’t be concerned about making your local trust fund kids’ private school experience a good bargain compared to public school. They should be doing the opposite.
They definitely should address the reasons why kids in low income districts enroll in charter schools, but charter schools themselves are a terrible band-aid solution.
eesmith
|root
|parent
|previous
[-]
The price for the private schools go up by the price of the voucher.
The private schools optimize for low-cost special needs students, and leave the high-cost special needs students up to the public schools, which have a much higher legal obligation to accept students than private schools.
The private schools with the best marketing for the most profitable students make the most money. This advertising money is not used on students.
Said no school system ever - let's make a bunch of small schools and forget about the economies of scale from consolidation.
yahthatsart
|root
|parent
|next
|previous
[-]
Also, you know how many people are making $600,000? It's not a lot of people. You know how many parents are making $600,000? It's even fewer people.
It's maybe a hundred kids. I'd rather just soak the cost of paying for 100 kids rather than spending WAY more counting to make sure those specific 100 kids don't get the benefit.
nine_k
|root
|parent
[-]
Put the list of paying parents prominently and nicely (not obscenely) for everyone to see. Mention their names, and make i understandable for the target audience that it's not that hard to get onto this list, and parents of cool kids are on it.
Completely ignore the real income of those desiring to pay. Maybe some families that make mere $500k, or even the pitiful $400k a year would participate.
skybrian
|previous
[-]
For other markets, sometimes people will claim that there's no such thing as a labor shortage if you pay enough. Somehow that doesn't seem to make sense for childcare?
spwa4
|root
|parent
[-]
With the exception of some schools (what I know about: the EU sponsored schools in Brussels and previously Antwerp) and some catholic schools that still do it, as well as technically the exception of partial subsidized childcare (which requires approval from the department Opgroeien and they're deliberately dragging their feet on approval as a way to save money).
But they are very few and very far between and for most access is limited in various ways. The EU schools only allow children of expat EU workers, and the catholic schools allow anyone but they're always full (just like regular childcare)
But generally the subsidies have resulted in jokes that any couple that even begins to think about a child immediately register for a spot in childcare. Because it takes half a decade to get a spot in the cities now.