Hacker News
How to Break into Security, Ptacek Edition (2012)
liquid_oil
|next
[-]
xyzzy123
|root
|parent
[-]
As for today, there was a shock from end of ZIRP and now AI.
On the AI side I guess one could read it as a ladder pull but it feels more structural to me? The entire field is in an existential crisis while we try to figure out what our jobs are now, what hiring criteria we should use, how work should be organised and what products might even be valuable anymore.
For boutique security specifically I can't say if it was difficult or easy to get hired in 2012, sort of both? The hardest part was figuring out where the ladder even was. It was hidden round the back of the building, next to the loading docks where people smoke. The hiring path was quietly "game recognise game", i.e, you learn & hack stuff in a safe way and people already doing that recognise that you can do the job. Certificates never mattered - that's not what anyone was looking for (by the time someone can certify you to do it, it's not really hacking anymore). I don't really see that changing.
sorentwo
|next
|previous
[-]
david_shaw
|next
|previous
[-]
But in 2026, tptacek says it best in the comments here: At this point, who knows?
Are we still telling kids to learn programming languages to become software developers? Perhaps system design is a more reasonable skill set.
That said, because this is the time to say it: security is still important, and it's not -- and shouldn't be -- fully automated.
The toolchain is changing just like it always has. I remember when interpreted languages replaced compiled ones, and people said that interpreters solved security. Then people went from writing their own codebases to implementing frameworks, and people said it solved security.
Barracuda Networks posters at every airport stated "Security Solved."
As long as people take risks, security is important. Now we just need to focus on designing resilient systems instead of finding bugs and vulns on the code-level. LLMs can do that part for us.
smashandgrab
|next
|previous
[-]
As for AI it’s been great for things like log review but those were already pretty low skill requirements. We haven’t had much luck past that.
bryant
|next
|previous
[-]
I'm anticipating "the fundamentals are crucial," and as much as I want to agree, I think practical realities show us otherwise. We're at a point where all someone needs to know is how to AI-program-manage and how to glean enough about the discipline (or any discipline at this point) from AI to be dangerous enough in the field. To be a builder, breaker, or defender wearing any color hat of their choosing... that's it, really.
dzonga
|next
|previous
[-]
what the incentives are since hacking seems to be no longer a crime given how many hacking incidents have gone unpunished.
uptrails
|root
|parent
[-]
On some level, nothing has changed - you still get noticed and hired the same way as before, the companies are still pretty much the same - but I just wouldn't have the confidence to tell anyone "hey kid, this is how it's going to look three years from now". It's not that I think these roles are going away, but there's a good chance they're going to be a lot less interesting (and not as well-paying) when it's all said and done.