Hacker News

US will say "no" to global ban on killer robots

37 points by madihaa ago | 26 comments

MisterBiggs |next [-]

The issue here is that by the time you realize your adversary stopped holding their punches the war will be over. Autonomous systems totally break conventional warfare, there is no ramp up period or chance of retaliation when the rules get broken. Things are going to move well beyond the pace of humans and software at the edge is going to make just as much of a impact as hardware.

bradthebeaverfa |next |previous [-]

Absent an enforcement mechanism, laws like this just reward countries that are more willing to ignore the law.

And the UN has repeatedly proven it does not have an effective enforcement mechanism.

carefulfungi |next |previous [-]

Would supporting this ban be perceived as more pressure on Ukraine?

kube-system |next |previous [-]

All UN members vote in their own self-interest.

I suspect the "yes" votes will coincide with the countries who stand to gain from the production or use of killer robots. And the "no" votes will coincide with states that have nothing to gain.

rescripting |root |parent |next [-]

Countries who stand to gain from the production or use of killer robots will vote "yes" on a ban of killer robots? How would this bolster use or production?

Spalau |root |parent |previous [-]

Killer robots already exist. The only choice is between being the ones getting shot or also having the ones doing the shooting.

simongr3dal |root |parent [-]

Why not both!

reasonableklout |next |previous [-]

> Rather than negotiating a binding treaty, the U.S. has proposed five more years of work by the CCW's expert group to develop a nonbinding instrument, according to a November 4 working paper.

> Washington maintains that existing international humanitarian law already applies to autonomous weapons and that a new legally binding treaty is unnecessary.

Sounds like diplomatic stalling

jmclnx |next |previous [-]

I wish I can say I am surprised, but I am not. There was a time when I believed these laws would become real, but now we know they won't.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Laws_of_Robotics

pixl97 |root |parent |next [-]

Even in the books where the hardware had this magic there were problems, and that was the entire point of the books.

Reality cannot work in the way the books did, at least not with any type of computing architecture we've made so far. I'd go further and say it's antithetical to general intelligence and problem solving.

Loquebantur |root |parent |previous [-]

A drone is a robot as well.

People use robots (and soldiers) to dodge responsibility. By making the operator anonymous, hidden beneath layers of "chain of command", the fiction of "nobody was responsible" is conjured up.

By refusing to outlaw autonomous weapons, the absence of any human operator built-in, the US follows its greed, their wish for killing without remorse and the fiction of "untouchability".

pixl97 |root |parent [-]

The US is the biggest arms dealer in the world, what made you think we were ever going to ban drones?

uptrails |next |previous [-]

We'll pass this right after WWIII.

I'm not even joking, almost every "ban on X" in the context of warfare happened after unspeakable atrocities where, once the dust settled, the parties involved looked at the sea of dead bodies and agreed not to do it again. I guess countries learn by doing.

tehjoker |root |parent |next [-]

This is mostly but not entirely true. An international ban on blinding laser weapons was enacted before they became widely used.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_on_Blinding_Laser_Wea...

vjvjvjvjghv |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Agreed. And after a few decades/centuries people will forget how bad war is and they will do it again.

analog31 |root |parent |previous [-]

I don't think we passed a global ban on nuclear weapons or land mines.

michaelt |root |parent |next [-]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottawa_Treaty 162 states have signed a land mine ban.

Non-signatories include the US, China, Russia, India, Pakistan, Israel and Iran. And Ukraine decided to withdraw from the treaty after being invaded by Russia.

So a ban with a lot of signatories, but not by any means universal.

vjvjvjvjghv |root |parent [-]

A lot of these treaties will be abandoned once a war becomes existential for a countyr. As far as I know, chemical and biological weapons weren't used in WW2 because they don't make much sense. Same for nuclear weapons after WW2. They aren't very useful and may trigger world wide destruction.

vjvjvjvjghv |root |parent |previous [-]

Land mines mainly rip off limbs of children and framers so nobody really cares. I think it's terrible by the US that haven't joined the ban.

As far as nuclear weapons go, they haven't been banned but we have the non-proliferation treaty that worked to some degree. The use of nuclear weapons is also viewed as a line that after WW2 nobody has tried to cross.

pixl97 |root |parent [-]

I think one of the biggest issues is the border between the Korea's. One of the more heavily mined areas in Earth.

spprashant |next |previous [-]

UN treaties are worth the paper they are written on. I doubt the current US admin cares much about any of the UN treaties, except for when it supports sanctions they want to impose.

In other slightly related news, the US Secretary of State made mockery of International Criminal Court this morning. https://www.reuters.com/world/us/rubio-assails-international...

BLKNSLVR |root |parent [-]

Rubio to International Law is Hegseth to Rules of Engagement.

If Rubio finds that an offensive parallel to draw, then it shows how much he has bent his reality lens.

tehjoker |next |previous [-]

This is similar to how America refuses to agree that food for children is a human right. At the UN, we are a supervillain.

fedpost |next |previous [-]

TBF we've had killer robots for decades. Every now and then we shoot down an airliner full of people with them.

Not to be overly glib but that cat has been out of the bag for a long fucking time. Name a capability and I'll give you a conventional munition that has had said capability for over a decade.

hadlock |root |parent [-]

We've had the Tomahawk since 1983, the Minuteman since 1962, and at a much smaller scale, the Javelin since 1996. If you want to go back further, the Germans had the V2 as early as 1944. The cat has been out of the bag almost as long as we've had the gift of flight, and predating the modern computer.

slowhadoken |previous [-]

JD Vance is a killer pleasure droid.