Hacker News

Ask HN: What do you think is going on with that many outages coming in a row?

8 points by vld_chk ago | 9 comments
In just four days we have seen:

* Outlook exchange server outage for almost 20 hours * FAA communication channels outage * A few US banks outage * United Airlines outage

Do you think it is related to AI coding, just coincidence or we start to see, but can’t detect, AI hijacking systems everywhere?

al_borland |next [-]

I'm wondering how much of it is simply related to what's being reported. After a big story like the Microsoft outage and FAA outage make headlines and garner a lot of attention, the media seems more likely to report on smaller outages that it may have otherwise overlooked, because it's now a hot topic.

For example, 2 years ago direct deposit was broken for CapitalOne. Their customers didn't get their paychecks for several days. What would normally get deposited early on Wednesday (for a Friday payday) didn't actually hit accounts until something like Tuesday of the following week. I don't recall seeing anything in the media, all I saw were people on Twitter tagging CapitalOne support left and right, talking about how they couldn't feed their families... and I only saw that because I went looking for it. If that happened this week, it would be headline news.

chistev |next |previous [-]

Are we in a middle of a huge Cyber warfare?

https://old.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/1xy058c/...

mikewarot |next |previous [-]

We made a rational choice back in the 1980s has resulted in a civilization wide problem now. We went with the popular Operating Systems of the day without concern about security, even though security focused systems existed at the time. Our systems were mostly stand alone, and we ran code we trusted locally, and had everything backed up, multiple copies, on floppy disks, so everyone had a good risk model in their heads, and life was good.

Then we stayed with this choice even after everything got networked locally. It wasn't too dodgy then because the code was still local and trusted, and you mostly worried about bugs, not hacking or malware.

We even stayed with it in the era of persistent gigabit Internet and mobile code. At this point it's insane to do so as we've got mobile code, malware, hackers, and now even rogue AI added to super empower anyone with even a hint of ill intentions.

Imagine if you awoke to find yourself in a parallel world, where things were identical, but there were zero fuses or circuit breakers anywhere in the power grid. What a nightmare, right? That's how I feel about this timeline with computers.

My conspiracy theory is: There was likely a meeting at the NSA back in the 1980s, where they decided NOT to push for capability based Operating Systems for the masses, because it would have taken effort to do so, and it would have made their jobs easier. As the consequences of this decision moved forward in time, their awareness of the horror has grown. Then the folks who understood this retired a decade or more ago.

markus_zhang |next |previous [-]

We don't have much information about any of these. It could be anything from new guys tripping off a landmine to cyber attacks. I wish insiders talk more about those, but apparently that's not a good advice.

k310 |next |previous [-]

Much as I love computer conspiracy theories, these may all be largely or entirely unrelated, and simply due to incompetence, but as usual, troubles are often from many causes. Try

  • Rushing patches in
  • Not patching
  • Incredible incompetence
  • Systems (refrigerators) too damn wide open, for script kiddies to have fun with

The government fired a lot of cybersecurity experts (thank DOGE), and companies don't want to spend time and money on security. Software is generally flawed, and attacks are coming at a much faster pace than fixes. The latest deal is to use AI to scrutinize AI-generated code, and good luck with that, and I just listened to a video linked here [0] in which key points are that AI is reaching a point where it can be truly dangerous as in "overthrow the government" and that we need to nonetheless race development because CHINA is racing development, and YET, the more advanced our models are, the more advantageous it is for China (or others) to simply steal it.

So, in defending against an "enemy" we are also doing their work for them. Nice. We have been down this path before, but maybe this is more dangerous than nukes. Maybe not.

AND that security from leakage within AI companies, while extremely crucial, is secret and therefore unknown.

Given the value of the inside information, it could rival past government espionage scandals, and its status is completely known.

This all seems to boil down to security issues, and the very deliberate weakening of cyber defenses, along with incompetent political hacks in charge, and the sudden arrival of powerful vulnerability detection and exploitation, could take it all down in 2017 if not sooner, even without outside attack.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50522546

legitster |next |previous [-]

Without getting too conspiratorial, it's pretty common every year for a bunch of software updates to get pushed early November in anticipation of code freezes around Thanksgiving. A spike of outages around this time is not uncommon in any given year - but the FAA ground stop was notable enough to draw extra attention to all subsequent outages.

mattbrewsbytes |root |parent |next [-]

This seems the most plausible. I highly doubt all these traditional, slow moving enterprises were token-maxing this past spring and these outages being the outcomes of that and latent bugs. If anything they have very slow, controlled releases of system/software updates. Maybe MSFT is the exception because they are a tech company.

vld_chk |root |parent |previous [-]

Ah, yes, the US is heading into thanksgiving. I am from the UK, so for me code freezes mostly a theme for December, but I think you are completely right here.

UmYeahNo |root |parent [-]

I had a colleague refer to the next 45 days as "American Ramadan" in most corporate offices. Instead of fasting from food, they fast from work.

|next |previous [-]

daraleiman |previous [-]

[dead]