Hacker News

Elderly people are buying Teslas for the 'full self-driving.' This is a problem

18 points by watermelon0 ago | 3 comments

tristanj [-]

I actually think this is a good thing. Elderly drivers, specifically those age 80+, have a significantly higher fatal accident rate than the general population. It's something like 10 times higher, per mile driven. Policymakers have discussed restricting elderly driving for public safety reasons, but politically this is difficult. The elderly are a strong voting block, and this would take rights away from them. It's not a simple policy to pass.

While Tesla FSD is nowhere near perfect, and does cause accidents, I do believe it's statistically safer than the average elderly driver.

4d4m |root |parent |next [-]

Terrifying. FSD requires full driver takover when ADAS features turn off. There is no mental contortion that could make an unsafe senior driver statistically safer with this technology, it can only increase the danger to themselves and other fleshy humans like us if they are not fit to drive.

Driving, especially with Level 2 ADAS, requires full attention, full stop.

Terr_ |root |parent |previous [-]

Alternate scenario: The problematic driver is "saved from themselves" by automation, but the lack of small early issues hides the growing fundamental problem--from others and possibly from themselves. Finally the illusion pops with a severe collision.

That's not really hypothetical, it happened to one of my elderly relatives. Medical issues left them with a worsening vision problem, and they bought a Tesla for the promised automation. After a few years they got into as serious crash and lost their license. They've been looking for weird loopholes like trying to temporarily live in another state to get a license there.