Hacker News

Firefox opens hotline for users sick of Microsoft shoving Edge down their throat

36 points by bundie ago | 35 comments

GuestFAUniverse |next [-]

Teams doesn't seem to work with Firefox.

I needed to access files of my son's school, that were only available via Teams.

I had to install the app, because Microsoft denied Firefox and Brave any access.

Time to call the regulators to cut down this monopoly.

hurfdurf |root |parent |next [-]

Which makes this whole mandatory "browser choice" dialog from years ago merely a performative action. No point making it easier for people to discover other browsers when the web is narrowing down to 1.5 browsers (Chrom*/Blink and Mobile Safari/Webkit, which benefits desktop Safari too). One federal(!) service I'm using is openly saying they're just supporting Chrome and Safari. Game over.

ErroneousBosh |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Teams works better in Firefox on Linux than either the native Windows client, or Edge on Windows.

Edit: I should say, it works better *for me* than the native client. I know very little about Windows so I might be "holding it wrong".

llacane |root |parent |next [-]

My kids have to use it, and at school Teams "native" app lags. Their PC are 10th generation i7 with 16gb of ddr4. I told them to use it with Firefox (I asked to have it installed in every school's pc) and there does not lag. So definitely not uncommon.

GuestFAUniverse |root |parent |previous [-]

I used it on Android.

stratos123 |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Have you tried presenting an Edge-like user-agent for the teams site only? If that works it'd be suggestive of it being intentional.

wolvoleo |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Even outlook web (business version) doesn't work properly with Firefox. I used it on Linux and I constantly (like multiple times a day) got this red bar saying I should refresh the page to sign back in, or even a passive-aggressive "we signed you out, you can close this page to finish" just as if I had chosen to log out.

When I change my user agent to edge on windows, guess what? I just stay signed in and everything works normally. But then I get constant captcha crap from cloudflare on other sites because they notice something is off about my browser.

It was the main reason to drop office 365 for me.

chocochunks |root |parent [-]

Ha I noticed that too, I find Outlook web always has trouble downloading attachments in Firefox but they mysteriously just work in Edge or Chrome. No idea why.

llacane |root |parent |next |previous [-]

I "have"* to use at work, and here in Europe it is not blocked.

Maybe that was a choice of your administration.

*actually it is not, this year I tried to see how buggy was. Next year I won't use it.

HackerThemAll |root |parent |previous [-]

I don't use Teams. Not everybody is locked in the MS bubble.

GuestFAUniverse |root |parent |next [-]

School of child is using Teams.

Apart from that I never need it.

apercu |root |parent |previous [-]

More than half of my clients use teams. Which means I need to use teams.

froh42 |next |previous [-]

Can I please have a Firefox hotline for being sick of Mozilla? Recently Firefox pushed its own ad down my throat. (Convince your friends to use FF).

pjmlp |next |previous [-]

Yes, because this is what the browser really needs for adoption.

stuaxo |root |parent [-]

It's some cute advertising and not particularly expensive.

pjmlp |root |parent [-]

It is an US based hotline, advertising to whom?

JoeBOFH |root |parent [-]

It got us talking about it? So I assume it’ll get some portion of mainstream tech news reporting it.

pjmlp |root |parent [-]

Talking is useless if they don't increase installations count.

JoeBOFH |root |parent [-]

That is kind of the point of marketing

pjmlp |root |parent [-]

Which for many people it is quite ineffective, it only serves to sell ad spots.

monegator |next |previous [-]

> EU users can uninstall Microsoft Edge just like any other app through Windows Settings

Then explain me why it keeps reappearing every couple of weeks then

tomkarho |root |parent [-]

Many Windows internal tools are probably tied to Edge (or IE) so it might be a recovery action when some tool screams "I need IE! Help!" and the OS reinstalls the browser to accommodate this behavior.

pjmlp |root |parent [-]

Yes, this kind of OS self healing was introduced in Windows 2000, as fix to those applications that kept installing into C:\windows\system32, instead of actually configure the PATH and registry to locate their DLLs and COM.

dlcarrier |next |previous [-]

Does this mean Firefox is going to stop shoving random Mozilla projects down their users' throats, is is this like Microsoft's Scroogled campaign, where they'll turn around and behave the exact same way as the company they're mocking?

|root |parent |next [-]

HackerThemAll |root |parent |next |previous [-]

What that would be, for instance? As a long time Firefox user I am somehow unaware of the things you're implicating here.

stratos123 |root |parent [-]

As a long time Firefox user, I am pretty annoyed by:

- sponsored shortcuts being enabled by default

- Firefox Sync ads being prominent in several menus

- an ad for Mozilla VPN being in the multi-account container menu (this one is hidable)

- the default search engines containing probably-sponsored entries such as ebay

On mobile, there's also:

- that time some sort of sports-related widget started being enabled by default (???)

- nagging notifications suggesting to set it as the default browser, and informing me that it blocks trackers (the latter seemingly not toggled by any in-browser option)

I still much prefer it to other browsers, but I'd recommend de-Mozillaed Firefox forks rather than the official Firefox.

netsharc |root |parent |next [-]

I still recall the ick I got when I saw this screen when I opened Firefox: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1791524

HackerThemAll |root |parent [-]

Oh you're really sensitive then. Even a benign "thank you" screen that can be closed in 1 second and forgotten eternally is intolerable to contemporary demanding users and causes extreme emotions. LOL!

netsharc |root |parent [-]

I asked myself "Should I waste my time and energy engaging with a dismissive tool who doesn't get it, try to make him see my point; or do I just shut up and let him be the tool that he is?". You're reading this so I picked poorly...

It's not just a "thank you" screen. This has 58 kudos so that's 60 people "really sensitive": https://connect.mozilla.org/t5/discussions/mozilla-now-only-... . And it shows how much more crap some people working for Mozilla spent their time implementing.

Ah yeah, let's not be sensitive to emotions like what the word "love" evokes being used cheaply to try to win browser userbase. Maybe whoever made that has collective autism and doesn't know how human emotion works. The effect that screen has is that it's made me never want to donate to Firefox...

JoeBOFH |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Some of these I get but having eBay in the search list? I assume it’s paid for and expect it. How else is Firefox gonna stay afloat? Someone has to pay for development.

HackerThemAll |root |parent |previous [-]

> sponsored shortcuts being enabled by default How do you think they pay the developers?

> nagging notifications suggesting to set it as the default browser

How that can possibly be annoying if you're a Firefox users and thusly perhaps set it as a default browsers?

I don't get demands of people in 2026.

mossTechnician |root |parent |next [-]

> How do you think they pay the developers?

With Google money.

If Mozilla needs more money than that, they can tighten their belt by giving less of it to other projects[0], or refrain from building (apparently) non-competitive competitors to things that already exist[1]. Ads should be a last resort IMO.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41681666

[1]; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50544738

stratos123 |root |parent |previous [-]

> How do you think they pay the developers?

With donations, I'd hope.

> How that can possibly be annoying if you're a Firefox users and thusly perhaps set it as a default browsers?

Simple: I have more than one Firefox( fork) on my phone and they all would like to nag me to be default browser.

mossTechnician |root |parent |previous [-]

I'm reminded of the Samsung ads mocking Apple users for missing features, only a couple years before Samsung took those features away from their own users.

It's unfortunate Mozilla does not apply their standards to themselves. Sure, Firefox doesn't shove features down your throat to the same degree that Microsoft shoves edge down Windows users' throats. But the fact they haven't committed to doing the opposite - instead focusing on implementing similar antipatterns that are slightly more configurable - is at odds with truly choice-oriented forks like Waterfox.

hulitu |previous [-]

How sweet. While doing Microsoft things (rounded GUI elements). Maybe Mozilla shall concentrate on its browser ?