Hacker News

Show HN: Math 2.0

23 points by tamnd ago | 7 comments

yorwba |next [-]

I think the idea of making the dependency graph of mathematical concepts concrete is a good one, but I'm not sure who the intended audience of this implementation is. Checking the completion levels, https://math2.tamnd.com/levels/W2/ 136 entries are supposedly usable, but they're mostly fairly advanced concepts that build on top of others without usable entries. So someone who has a few gaps in their high-school education, for example, would have a hard time filling those gaps with this resource, because the foundations are missing. It might be better to take a leaf from the sequencing of existing math curricula, starting with full coverage of kindergarten math, to ensure that all topics ultimately bottom out in something everyone can understand.

zerocinante |root |parent [-]

It's definitely interesting. Maybe a use case would be someone interested in a topic to see a broad picture of the field so he can identify and fill those gaps you are talking about.

alper111 |next |previous [-]

What's the user scenario on this? For instance, why wouldn't I just go to Wikipedia?

orsenthil |next |previous [-]

A lot of information, it will difficult to assimilate. I appreciate the thought process that went into this.

gavmor |root |parent [-]

Agreed. What is the expected approach/user journey, here?

tnspacetime |next |previous [-]

It also includes physics, why is it called Math 2.0?

XTXinverseXTY |previous [-]

https://math2.tamnd.com/wiki/lagrangian-duality/

I am familiar with this concept but frankly I found the "In plain words" section impenetrable

> Instead of forbidding a constraint violation, one can charge a price for it. For each choice of prices one solves an easier problem without constraints, and its value is never above the true optimum.