Hacker News

Is AI a bicycle for the mind, or a car?

24 points by mrkn1 ago | 18 comments

tapoxi |next [-]

I've been thinking a car is a perfect analogy for a long time.

* Much faster to get from A to B

* Bad for the environment

* Doesn't exercise you

* Formerly pedestrian spaces redesigned to be car/AI first

* Hard to go back

* Despite most people needing a simple Corolla (open weight or cheap model) many people want to drive a more expensive F150 (Opus) because it's better in edge cases

* Reckless users cause accidents (huggingface)

jmathai |next |previous [-]

The cognitive decline which results from using AI is more similar to the effects on your health of trading walking in for an automobile rather than a bike.

That's coming from someone who uses AI heavily.

leobg |next |previous [-]

A horse.

> Oh, thou hast mounted on horseback? Thou now ridest briskly up to thy goal? Well, my friend! But along with thee on horseback rideth thy lame foot.

—Nietzsche

K0balt |next |previous [-]

A computer is a bicycle for the mind. AI is a car.

stryakr |next |previous [-]

It's more like a e-Bike than either one thing.

Sometimes you need to use it as a motorized vehicle, other times you just need a little bit of assistance but, and sometimes it's just there to exist as a bike.

DrNosferatu |next |previous [-]

Future AIs will solve the cognitive decline:

they will become some sort of "optimal bike". But right now it's more of a car with its downsides.

coffeebeqn |root |parent [-]

Why would future models be more like bikes? I’d think they’d be more like teleports

ncrmro |root |parent |next [-]

I would presume future AI would be a bit more included to recognized when the user has gaps in their knowledge that need to be addressed rather than just predicting the next token

add-sub-mul-div |root |parent [-]

If you presume anything other than future AI will be optimized to extract money from you and from the people you being sold to as a product, then you're being irresponsibly naive.

DrNosferatu |root |parent |previous [-]

Read excercise bike.

jsat |next |previous [-]

It's a car in that heavy users ignore the negative externalities and risks of their own actions while complaining about everyone else.

paradox460 |next |previous [-]

Isn't it a bicycle for a pelican?

randysalami |next |previous [-]

The harness is the X-Wing, the LLM is R2-D2, the pilot is Luke Skywalker, and the force is that spark which some engineers can tap into, disciplined mental, physical, and emotional training. Nobody says R2-D2 blew up the Death Star!!

akomtu |next |previous [-]

A car with buggy autopilot that will happily drive you into the oncoming traffic at 70 mph.

metalman |next |previous [-]

AI is like a bicycle for a fish, realy hard and expensive to make, but the fish cant be made to use it.

Fricken |previous [-]

AI is a mind for the car and potentially also the bicycle, although no one to my knowledge has built very good minds for bicycles.

pwdisswordfishq |root |parent [-]

A car is a mind for an AI.

lioeters |root |parent [-]

The mind of humanity is the automobile for the AI.