Hacker News

Show HN: Beat – a to-do list that completes its own tasks

15 points by brdo ago | 9 comments

brdo [-]

Hi HN, I’m Brendan.

We were originally building a completely different product (an office workplace app: desk booking, food ordering, etc.) and built Beat internally to keep up with our own work. It ended up being the thing we used most. What we actually cared about was whether our work got done on time, and whether we were the ones blocking the team. So I figured you guys might like using it as well.

Beat starts working the moment something is assigned to you and gets put in your to-do. It handles your PRs, meeting notes, Jira tickets, and you just approve.

The code review tools we tried either missed real defects or overclaimed false positives, so I've really been focusing on providing high quality code reviews on every single commit, not just commit diff, but running against entire repos, and I would really love if you guys would try it out and give me some feedback on how it feels.

It’s a totally free beta, open to anyone with a Google account.

saaaaaam |root |parent [-]

I’m curious why you think anyone would trust this obviously vibe coded app to the point they share data with it? That’s a genuine question. I read this completely incomprehensible but of text about security and thought “absolutely not”.

> Prompt injection can't act through Beat: the worst a hidden instruction in a PR can do is change a draft you read first. Hosted by CXAI on Google Cloud. Full security details

Like, what does that even mean? That is not any sort of English as she is wrote.

Edit: Good grief. You are apparently a nasdaq listed company. What on earth? (Albeit it one that peaked at $692.50 a share in 2023 and is now trading at $1.25 a share…)

brdo |root |parent |next [-]

Great point Sam, I sent the "vibed" feedback to our UI person haha

But it's a great point on data and privacy and it's one that I am personally proud of. We do NOT store any data, we do not train, we do not sell, we don't distribute any data. We are a fully SOC II compliant company. I'm an old-school dev, so I understand where you're coming from entirely.

It's good to know that the wording is not clear, the wording WAS almost entirely vibed. We have been building this product to help build our core products, and didn't particularly care about messaging, or coherence, so I do appreciate the feedback and will work on changing that.

The point on hidden instructions is about "open" agents and their ability to do things outside of the intended instruction. Beat does NOT behave like a traditional "open" agent, it simply CAN'T run outside of it's intended scope.

Yes, we are a nasdaq listed company. This is not our core product. Like I mentioned this is an internal tool, that we have found to be very useful, so I decided to see if others would find value in it.

nathancahill |root |parent |next [-]

"UI person"

brdo |root |parent [-]

LOL! It's true... Figma and all

If you're referring to the login page, then that makes sense. That's what I was saying was just vibed for this. The actual app looks nothing like the login.

Do you think the actual app is vibed? Or did you mean the login page? Would appreciate the feedback

sharkmerry |root |parent [-]

The video screencaps of the app look vibe coded, and they look similar to the published site advertising the product.

brdo |root |parent [-]

You think the video examples feel like the landing page?

Well we should definitely go back to the drawing board with our UI then because we did not vibe the actual product UI at all...

Thanks! I'm as turned off as the next person about "vibed" products so it's good to know for sure

saaaaaam |root |parent |previous [-]

I don’t understand why you would put what you claim is a legit product out into the market with “almost entirely vibed” copy. Did nobody stop and think and say “this makes the whole,e thing look vibes and will destroy trust in what we have built”?

brdo |root |parent |next [-]

I see where you and a few others are coming from completely. I didn't think it would come across as a "sales" pitch, I truly just wanted feedback on our code review quality more than anything else.

I get why it feels like a "sales" pitch, and maybe Show HN was the wrong place for this. The first impression is totally off-putting for the exact people I want feedback from... real, experienced devs, and we will definitely try to improve that.

But seriously, thank you for the feedback, and for taking time to comment, even if it's mostly about the landing page. The app itself was not remotely vibed, but I totally see why it comes across that way.

The whole team was in a Slack huddle for a couple of hours dissecting your comment, and we are definitely taking it seriously! (half of us were trying to play gta 6 during the huddle though, including me...)

star_boi |root |parent |previous [-]

[dead]

poetic_peanut |root |parent |previous [-]

[flagged]