Hacker News

Air Force Maj. Jason Watson has been in solitary confinement for almost 100 days

50 points by o_-_o ago | 18 comments

o_-_o |next [-]

“Who I am is immaterial,” Watson said at a news conference at the time. “In the grand scheme of things, I’m just a nobody. What matters far more than who I am is what I have to say and the price I’m willing to pay to say it.” -- Air Force Maj. Jason Watson

vintermann |next |previous [-]

The loyalty requirements on air force officers in particular seem unhinged. I had heard about the persecution of Dan Duggan, but not about this guy. This is some mafia level "we own you" shit.

caidan |next |previous [-]

Now this man is a hero. Would that we all had such strength of conviction and courage to speak the truth at such great personal cost. A great American and a model citizen.

vfclists |next |previous [-]

Aren't any of his "fellow officers" coming out to support him?

Why should being a serving military officer curtail his freedom of speech?

So the military who are supposed to defend the constitution apparently don't have those constitutional rights themselves, and a quite happy to punish their fellow members for exercising those rights.

What a joke!!

rpdillon |root |parent |next [-]

Former U.S. Navy officer here.

When you're wearing the uniform, you don't get to do whatever you want: you are acting as an official of the United States government. And you do indeed give up your constitutional rights when you join the military.

None of it is a joke. It's all very intentional and well thought out. This particular officer knew exactly what he was doing, and being arrested was the point. It's a form of protest in this case.

You can read more about the curtailment of constitutional rights for service members here: https://www.humanrightsfirst.org/library/beyond-the-uniform-...

moioci |root |parent [-]

Sure, but pretrial detention and particularly solitary confinement seem very punitive for someone who has not yet been convicted. Certainly unnecessary from the public safety perspective.

vfclists |root |parent [-]

My thoughts exactly. Fact is you have had the commander of U.S. Southern Command (SOUTHCOM) resign on account of Trump's deranged behaviour. And we have these deeply questionable decision on the part of Trump to attack Iran with all its consequences.

People seem to have forgotten that in his first term there were some calls to have him removed from office under the 25th Amendment, yet another 4 years later he seems right as rain.

The US and its Joint Chiefs of Staff or whoever are complicit in this bizarre behaviour and to put this officer through this mental and physical torture for his performative act seemingly as a deterrent only show that the US military is in a dark place.

I doubt the US military treats prisoners of war captives in this manner.

ABoredBirb |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Not an american, but going to assume that rules of conduct for military personel are somewhat similar over there. The military is supposed to remain apolitical. This does not mean that the personnel can't express their political stances, they just can't be wearing their uniforms or otherwise claim to represent the military.

o_-_o |root |parent |next |previous [-]

We live in upside down world where criminals are in white house and real patriots are in jail.

SapporoChris |root |parent |next |previous [-]

Active-duty personnel can't engage in partisan political activity. Everyone serving should be well aware of this. The higher rank someone is that breaks military rules, the stiffer the penalty is.

vfclists |root |parent [-]

What is partisan about criticizing the President's actions?

Is he supporting one political party of the other?

Why should the prosecution of actions justifying impeachment be a partisan thing?

Isn't the law supposed to be blind?

cowlevel |root |parent |previous [-]

The USA doesn't seem to have any constitional rights any more, but I don't think the military ever had them. They're supposed to serve and obey until the end of their service, then they get discarded like everyone else.

eesmith |root |parent [-]

Soldiers absolutely have constitutional rights.

rpdillon |root |parent [-]

Kind of, but they are curtailed. I posted the link in another comment, but one example is around freedom of speech.

> One of the most visible rights gaps for service members is around speech. While civilians can openly criticize government policies or military leadership under the First Amendment, service members are subject to stricter restrictions. They risk punishment for social media posts, dissent, or public criticism of superiors.

> A prominent example is Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller, who in 2021 publicly criticized military leadership over the chaotic U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan in a viral video. He was relieved of command soon after for a “loss of trust and confidence.” Later, he pleaded guilty to six charges under the UCMJ, including contempt toward officials and disobeying orders, and was sentenced to a letter of reprimand and forfeited pay.

https://www.humanrightsfirst.org/library/beyond-the-uniform-...

eesmith |root |parent [-]

The correct response to "I don't think the military ever had them." is "soldiers absolutely have constitutional rights."

Even curtailed rights are still rights. The UCMJ is subordinate to the constitution.

Civilian public employees also have stricter restrictions than a private citizen who is not a government employee. See Pickering v. Board of Education, leading to the Pickering Balancing Test for Government Employee Speech - https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-1/p...

I believe the UCMJ as in your example uses a similar balancing analysis, though of course in a different framework.

stevenalowe |previous [-]

If only Congress took their duty as seriously as this officer

ivell |root |parent [-]

Can the new congress somehow help him?

stevenalowe |root |parent [-]

They can heed his warnings and impeach quickly