Hacker News

AI Overworks People

34 points by cmpit ago | 22 comments

bemtevi |next [-]

> AI's promise was to allow people to work less and get more done.

In my view, working less is not a great trade if the remaining work is boring as shit. Not sure about others, but I've had a few great jobs and a few horribly boring jobs, and I'd take the former over the latter any day. Spending even five hours a day at something boring, at least to me, is way worse than spending eight hours a day at something exciting. Maybe the equation would be different if it were just one boring hour. But that's not going to happen.

Besides, I also don't understand "getting more done". I don't care about getting more done. I think it's enough to get a reasonable amount of work done within the bounds of human abilities only. I hate productivity.

coldtea |root |parent |next [-]

>In my view, working less is not a great trade if the remaining work is boring as shit. Not sure about others, but I've had a few great jobs and a few horribly boring jobs, and I'd take the former over the latter any day.

With AI going forward you'll still get boring as shit work, just more of it, and for less pay.

testerius |root |parent |next |previous [-]

So what are these exciting things and work? Does it make you more stressful person?

bemtevi |root |parent [-]

Exciting things is making art without the creativity being interfered with. I don't see why you'd ask whether it makes me more stressful. I'm less stressed when I can just be in charge of figuring things, doing technical stuff and understanding the logic on a deep level.

When I can do lower-level stuff and just work on problems, that's fun. When it's all about production and efficiency, that's boring.

exe34 |root |parent |previous [-]

Is that why you still work in the fields during daylight hours?

coldtea |root |parent |next [-]

Nothing bad with working in the fields during daylight hours.

Except that they made it a bad economic choice.

bemtevi |root |parent |previous [-]

So you're attempting to refute my arguments by going to an extreme opposite? I'm arguing basically that there's an inflection point or point of diminishing returns in technological development and you're going to the beginning of the curve, so to speak?

Some arguing skills you have there.

exe34 |root |parent [-]

"I think it's enough to get a reasonable amount of work done within the bounds of human abilities only. I hate productivity."

Surely growing potatoes is a reasonable amount of work done within the bounds of human abilities - why would you want more productivity than than?

bemtevi |root |parent |next [-]

> Surely growing potatoes is a reasonable amount of work done within the bounds of human abilities - why would you want more productivity than than?

I can do a lot more than just grow potatoes, so I think that's fine to do that. But I don't think it's fine to use AI.

exe34 |root |parent [-]

coldtea |root |parent |previous [-]

>Surely growing potatoes is a reasonable amount of work done within the bounds of human abilities - why would you want more productivity than than?

I don't. Any other argument?

exe34 |root |parent [-]

Back to your field then, leave the adults to discuss technology.

xugencheng2024 |next |previous [-]

[flagged]

poxlr |next |previous [-]

[flagged]

evek |next |previous [-]

It’s interesting to see how many neurotypicals get overwhelmed by ai multitasking, while it seems more like “the usual way” to some neurodivergent people, especially with ADHD.

coldtea |root |parent |next [-]

ADHD still get overwhelmed. ADHD is not "good at multitasking" is "bad at maintaining focus on something not interesting".

Task switching in ADHD makes the boredom of several uninteresting in themselves things less, doesn't increase the productivity. The great productive ADHD mode is lost in hyperfocus on a single interesting thing for hours, not task switching.

aunderscored |root |parent |next |previous [-]

I (AuHD) very much for better when I can have multiple task switch options. It allows me to become bored of something and swap to something else. For $work it seems as if I am on top of things, but really my goal is to keep myself interested.

Agents however completely drain this. Watching something do nothing for 45 minutes is just boring.

14u2c |root |parent [-]

> Agents however completely drain this. Watching something do nothing for 45 minutes is just boring.

You just need more agents running :) Stagger them so they need input at different times and you got a nice rotation of attention going.

coldtea |root |parent |next [-]

>You just need more agents running :) Stagger them so they need input at different times and you got a nice rotation of attention going.

Might as well leave the profession altogether is that babysitting crap is the last thing we do before replaced by AI supervisors of those same agents.

aunderscored |root |parent |previous [-]

Ah yes. Permanently babysitting juniors and reviewing their code.... Exactly what I ean to do.

Regardless, that is all the same kind of thing. This makes me bored

apercu |root |parent |next |previous [-]

I don’t think every adhd person likes multitasking. Many actually find context switching exhausting.

coldtea |root |parent |next [-]

ADHD is basically constant multi-tasking and inability to focus unless the task is interesting.

So context switching doesn't increase ADHD productivity, it's the very failure mode of ADHD. Hyperfocus through great interestingness of a specific task is the ADHD hyperproductivity thing.

throw-the-towel |root |parent |previous [-]

I love multitasking on my own initiative. Not so much being forced to switch tasks by an agent.

exe34 |root |parent |previous [-]

I'm certified autistic and adhd. Multitasking is what I do when none of it matters and I'm just killing time. If the results can get me paid or fired, single tasking is the only way to avoid costly mistakes.

cumshitpiss |previous [-]

[dead]