Hacker News

Carbon Emissions of US Data Centers Rival Countries

23 points by sandinmyjoints ago | 10 comments

Kim_Bruning |next [-]

At least data centers can run 100% renewable in theory, so hopefully this is a solvable problem over time.

nisegami |next |previous [-]

I am an AI maximalist, but I would support efforts or legislation to require new data centers to use renewables+battery storage. As I understand it, some questionably situated data centers even use on-site gas turbines which result in noise pollution affecting nearby residential communities. Mandating the use of renewables+storage would prevent AI opponents from being able to claim noise pollution, energy cost increases passed on to other consumers or fossil fuel use as reasons to oppose data center buildouts.

filoeleven |root |parent [-]

More than "some":

> Natural gas and coal together are expected to meet over 40% of the additional electricity demand from data centres until 2030.

https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-and-ai/energy-supply-for-...

nisegami |root |parent [-]

My "some" was referring to data centers with on-site energy production from fossil fuels. Doing that changes the implications of living or working near to a data center. I imagine the 40% number includes energy obtained from the grid, which is not really what I was referring to.

vivzkestrel |next |previous [-]

- is it true that you can run a 2TB kimi k3 model on 8GB of RAM?

- https://medium.com/@fareedkhandev/a5792cbf3b59?sk=7772001b26...

- if this is indeed true, wouldnt it render all data centers obsolete?

|root |parent |next [-]

hhnn1776dg9 |root |parent |previous [-]

At 2 tokens PER MINUTE?

dan_grec |next |previous [-]

It would be really interesting to see the long term health impacts on everyday Americans as a result of this.

The US is once again making piles of cash for some people, but at what cost?

rayiner |root |parent [-]

> The US is once again making piles of cash for some people, but at what cost?

AI companies are losing money hand over fist. It's a highly competitive market and right now the benefits are going to the consumer, not the provider. The environmental costs should be attributed to the ultimate consumer who gets the benefit, not the producer that is, for now, losing money providing the service.

Most of the industries that generate the most carbon emissions are competitive industries where price competition decimates profits and causes most of the surplus to flow to the consumer. Exxon's profit margin over the last 5 years averages 10%. Even right now with the high gas prices, their profit margin for the last quarter was only 14%. These companies have enormous revenues, but they also spend huge amounts of money turning dead dinosaurs into usable fuel. Most of the benefit goes to American consumers, so they can live spread far apart from each other in houses twice as big as those in Europe and drive their fat asses through the drive through to get their morning Starbucks.

By all accounts, AI is going to be a continuation of this trend. We'll have multiple competing companies driving prices to efficient levels, and most of the surplus will go to consumers so they can turn their brains off while drinking their Starbucks and watching Tik Tok in the background.

hollerith |root |parent [-]

You make it sound like the supermarket business whereas it look radically different than that to me.

Since 2021, OpenAI has raised about $192 billion and Anthropic has raised $245.9 billion including today's IPO. Both are spending a large fraction of that money in an attempt to create models that are much more powerful than the models they have today. I'm tempted to suggest that the main reason they offer services to the public and generate revenue is to make themselves more attractive to investors. (E.g., they hope that prospective investors will interact with Claude or ChatGPT and be impressed with the result that they choose to invest in the company.)

In July 2025, WIRED reported that Meta had offered some researchers compensation packages worth up to $300 million over 4 years, including equity. Meta was willing to offer that much because like OpenAI and Anthropic, they are trying for a model that is much more powerful than any of today's models. It wouldn't make sense to offer that much to a single researcher in the hopes that that researcher will help Meta make the process of serving inference more efficient, which you seem to think will be the main arena of competition between the labs.

(I've focused on OpenAI and Anthropic because Meta and Google are harder for an outsider to analyze because they have diverse businesses and are required only to report company-wide financials, not the financials of every specific business they are in.)

The nation's largest grocery retailers don't spend many 10s of $billions trying to create grocery stores or retail experiences that are vastly better than the stores or experiences they offer today.

The world's petroleum producers do spend vast sums every year to get petroleum, but they don't spend $10 of billions in addition to that in an attempt to get a product that is qualitatively superior to the product they currently offer.

copperx |previous [-]

We went from NIMBY to "totally in my backyard," which is a moral improvement, at least.