Hacker News

Microsoft is killing To Do and telling you to "choose another" app

26 points by taubek ago | 16 comments

harshalizee |next [-]

MS killed Wunderlist for this. It is still by far the best todo app design I've ever used. They tried to migrate people over to Microsoft ToDo, but their arcane auth system failed to transfer over anything nor let me login into the new app, so that was that.

gherkinnn |root |parent [-]

Oh the feels, I loved Wunderlist. How time flies. MS' arcane auth system also locked me out of my ancient Minecraft account, so there's that.

netruk44 |next |previous [-]

I used to use Wunderlist/ToDo a long time ago. And many others. But I frequently got annoyed at the arbitrary limitations made to get you to become a monthly subscriber.

A few years ago I moved to “self hosting” Vikunja and haven’t really looked back. (Quotes because it’s on a rented VPS, so it’s not true self hosting)

Infinite projects, a PWA for my phone’s app launcher, free data export and backups to whatever format and destination I want.

And free API access, too. I’ve built a voting feature into my apps based on my Vikunja tasks so that my users can vote on what I should implement next.

amanaplanacanal |next |previous [-]

I've been using it in my phone for shopping lists. Guess I'll have to find something else.

VeraGreen |root |parent [-]

[flagged]

RadiozRadioz |next |previous [-]

I started using this at work because I needed a todo app one day and it came pre-installed with Windows on the company laptop. It does the job fine, nothing special. Even going into it I was skeptical of its longevity, having been repeatedly burned by MSFT and Google randomly killing products. Turns out my suspicions were correct. Sigh.

I don't think I'm able to rely on apps produced by these companies any more. Aside from their main products, everything else is just one re-org or direction change away from the grave. They already lost my trust, and now I'm at abject distrust. No matter how good they make these apps, they simply can't be relied on.

science4sail |root |parent [-]

The problem with relying on big companies for small products is that since those products are only a negligible fraction of overall revenue, their survival relies more on internal politics than on profitability or market fit.

Google was notorious for this with chat apps during the 2010s. A PM or director would launch an app right before the performance review cycle, viciously defend it as the next new thing during the cycle, and abandon it after getting their promotion. Engineering would complain about this (but also be complicit since many SWEs relied on this phenomenon for their own career growth).

rolandf |next |previous [-]

Very unreliable company.

fred_is_fred |next |previous [-]

I've been using Planner as part of office, launched as a Chrome app since there's no native client for MacOS. It does the job. Trello was my previous choice.

heisgone |next |previous [-]

I have developed a spydey sense of which Microsoft features will survive the test of time and for some esoteric reasons, I "knew" this one wouldn't. For a feature to survive, it has to become too hard to kill, and todo never met that threshold.

Another feature I see having the same fate is Loop. We should bet on polymarket on that.

tartieret |next |previous [-]

I have been trying to use it for the last 2 weeks, for personal work-related tasks. The experience is terrible, it's a piece of garbage. Crazy that Microsoft cannot put together a nice todo app, well integrated with the rest of the ecosystem and accessible through MCP

YuechenLi |next |previous [-]

I thought they were merging Planner, To Do, and Projects together since they had 3 products that essentially does the same exact thing slightly differently for some weird reason. But the lack of migration from To Do to Planner is very frustratingly Microsoft.

xet7 |root |parent [-]

You can import Microsoft To Do to WeKan FLOSS kanban, and export to Microsoft Planner, for free online:

https://boards.wekan.team

https://wekan.fi/app/

Or install WeKan to your laptop:

- AppImage at https://github.com/wekan/wekan/releases

More install options at https://wekan.fi/install/

YuechenLi |root |parent [-]

Interesting. You are the lead dev for this right? Can you tell me more about it? It looks a bit complicated for my need from the screenshot, do you have a demo version I can try without registration?

llimos |next |previous [-]

Fortunately, you can just run any web framework tutorial instead

vcryan |previous [-]

It's okay. I didn't want to do anything anyway.

tonyedgecombe |root |parent [-]

I'm making a To Don't list. Things I plan to never do. Top of the list is using any Microsoft products ever again.