Hacker News

Google says it's going to shut off Google Assistant on smart speakers next year

10 points by speckx ago | 9 comments

Marsymars |next [-]

I've been declining the prompt every time it comes up in my Google Home app.

> Google argues that Gemini for Home allows users to ask more complex questions and speak naturally instead of needing to use dedicated commands or specific language.

This isn't something I want for my home speakers. I just want speakers that take dedicated commands to control my smart home things deterministically.

It's effectively a mildly fancy light switch. I don't need a light switch to run an LLM to process whether it's been toggled on or off.

netsharc |next |previous [-]

Google did announce they were killing Assistant on the phone in September. I haven't updated my phone, and I still have it. I started vibe coding a replacement app (using Gemini-assisted Android Studio), but lost motivation. The speech recognition even happens on device

And I have a Lenovo Smart Clock, when they kill Assistant for this, it'll be my first manufacturer-induced e-waste. It'll make me hate Google even more, just telling the device what time to wake me up, or adding reminders for the next day as they come to my mind as I'm trying to sleep, has been very convenient the last ~4 years of my life.

computer23 |next |previous [-]

It would be nice to be able to flash an old smart speaker with a custom Linux...

Incidentally, I asked the new Google home what time it was in India the other day, and it was 5 hours off.

ccoreilly |root |parent [-]

You can do it with the original Alexa Echo Dot. Claude had no issue hooking it up to HomeAssistant running an assistant.

|next |previous [-]

m-p-3 |next |previous [-]

It pulled the plug on my smart speaker. It was working decently for some commands through Google Assistant and it was able to do so in both languages I speak (English and French).

When Gemini came on, it was a downgrade: it wouldn't understand the commands that were working before, and it wouldn't understand commands in French, despite trying to gaslight me by telling me that I was wrong and that it could.

Good riddance to that piece of junk.

jlundberg |next |previous [-]

damnesian |next |previous [-]

>The company will also automatically transfer Nest Aware (1st Gen) subscriptions to Google Home Premium.

I have to assume the subs will be a lot more expensive too.

demo4567 |previous [-]

hahahahahahaha. and they want me to use Gemini Todos...