Hacker News

Army delays detonating "catastrophically hazardous" lead azide amid fear, anger

31 points by Bender ago | 11 comments

PaulHoule |next [-]

whoanoway |root |parent [-]

[dead]

metalman |next |previous [-]

exothermic reaction @ 18000 k/h, but there are going to be ways to dampen that reaction, even just boring deep barrel sized holes in the ground and detonating underground and then cleaning up the mess has to be better than spreading toxic lead over hundreds of square miles, most of it could be done with tracked robot handlers once the holes get drilled.

Jtsummers |root |parent [-]

> just boring deep barrel sized holes in the ground and detonating underground

The reported concern (I need to talk to a buddy of mine who did this kind of work to find out more from an expert, so I am just regurgitating the reporting until I do that) is that the barrels are sufficiently unstable to make even moving them a challenge. That would include moving them into barrel sized holes in the ground. This is why they've built up structures around the barrels in place.

Though I do agree, reading through the article some of the concerns could have been addressed by robots. Like the concern around adding stabilizing agents into the barrels. Build up the barriers (as they have done) and then send in the robots. The problem with that is that it could explode any day, which means a potentially weeks long evacuation for the area. But if it succeeds, then the only harm is the evacuation. If it partially succeeds, then it should still reduce the amount of environmental damage. And if it fails (essentially, an explosion on the first day) then it's no worse a plan than the current one.

ajb |root |parent |next [-]

The stuff has to be pretty heavy. I wonder if it's possible to design a vortex filter sufficiently low resistance that the explosion shockwave would pass through it, but the plume of lead would be trapped. I'm picturing a dome entirely made of vortex filters, like the world's biggest Dyson vacuum cleaner...

|root |parent [-]

metalman |root |parent |previous [-]

didn't see anything, but I wonder if flooding the barrels with liquid nitrogen can temporarily render the lead azide non explosive for robot transfer to an underground detonation/containment chamber

Jtsummers |root |parent [-]

Colder temperatures also make this less stable, per the reporting. I can't imagine a sudden rapid cooling would be better than gradual cooling in this case. When you don't want to move the barrels because you're worried vibrations could cause detonation, you probably don't also want to suddenly freeze the suspension as that can also cause movement, internally, that would likely also increase the chance of detonation.

It's a lose-lose situation. The right time to address this was years ago, and that didn't happen. Now they have a bunch of materials that will explode (it's just a matter of when) so the best option out of all the bad options is the controlled detonation. The only positive outcome of this might be Congressional awareness of how bad these old explosives have been managed and a more deliberate effort out of their to push for proper cleanup of these kinds of depots. That's not likely, though, we'll just get a bunch of hearings instead.

EmX_3000 |next |previous [-]

It's cool nobody eats corn or soybeans from that area. I don't see what the fuss is about.

adamredwoods |root |parent [-]

Except for families that live there.

EmX_3000 |root |parent [-]

It's true, that part of Iowa into Illinois is largely known for subsistence corn and bean farming.

aetherspawn |next |previous [-]

Ah, something completely illegal that would require probably 20 ungrantable permits, except in America.

It sounds like the army doesn’t even have a management plan for this chemical.

astrodust |previous [-]

Just let NileRed fix it.