Hacker News

This Industrial Revolution Belongs to the Builders

10 points by pacificmaelstrm ago | 15 comments
You've heard AI = Labor. Therefore Labor -> 0.

Some people think this means that only asset owners, people with lots of capital, will come out ahead.

They're wrong.

Because as a builder/founder, you create value.

Capital must capture some of this value to have a return.

The reason founders primarily need capital is to pay for labor (either employees or supplier overhead).

So this means that Capital ~= Labor.

But that's a problem for the "owners of capital will own everything" narrative, because now we have:

AI = Labor = Capital -> 0

In practice this will happen slowly as builders need less and less capital to build, capital will increasingly struggle to capture value created by builders.

Counterintuitively this means valuations will climb dramatically reflecting capital paying more and more to capture less and less value from builders.

As disruption accelerates, volatility increases while broader market wide returns start to stagnate.

The net will be a wholesale wealth and power transfer from capital holders to builders/founders, on the magnitude of what happened between the aristocracy and the capitalist class in the earlier industrial revolutions.

It's already started, companies are raising later and at higher valuations.

Most people accept that if superintelligence were created, capital would be useless, but what they often don't realize is that a class of builders armed with AI is already creating a distributed superintelligence that will have the same effect.

Interested if anyone else shares this perspective.

markus_zhang |next [-]

I think the people who benefit:

1. Big Capital who controls the infrastructure of AI, electricity, etc. And the people they hire to maintain them.

2. Elite builders (programmers) who can leverage AI and build products everyone needs. They are more like rock stars.

3. Deep state people who control military and intelligence, because violence always gets its share.

4. Auxiliary interest groups like some politicians, some other big capitals, etc.

Everyone else gets screwed.

Oh, someone might be lucky enough to be the Mafia of the underworld, because there gotta be someone who maintains law and order.

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent [-]

My take on your thoughts:

1. I think AI will move to the edge way faster than anyone thinks, rendering the "AI infrastructure" play a mirage/commodity.

2. Anyone can be a builder with AI, but many people just won't even write the prompts since AI will also create ever more distracting forms of entertainment.

3. The old elites will be largely replaced, creating an opportunity to effect real change in government, like in the last industrial revolution when the Aristocracy were pushed aside

4. Nothing's, perfect, but I think we should be optimistic. Things got a lot better in the last Industrial revolution, there's no reason that it can't happen this time. People didn't think the aristocrats lose their power back then either until it happened.

TFNA |root |parent |next [-]

If people are distracted by ever more distracting forms of entertainment, who will affect change in (democratic) countries? With the rise of television and social media, people have become more and more aloof from local political participation, either treating politics as a spectator sport or sinking into outright apathy.

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent [-]

The builders. And they will make changes to insure value creation is rewarded over the old paradigms of value extraction.

markus_zhang |root |parent |previous [-]

I wish I could be optimistic, but I'm over 40 with a family, and the last thing I want is to lose my job. I don't care how optimistic the world is in 20 years, to be frank. And I guess many people share the same sentiments. Not to blame on AI but it definitely doesn't help.

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent [-]

What is your job?

markus_zhang |root |parent [-]

Programmer.

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent |next [-]

The idea that engineers will be replaced by AI is wishful thinking by people who's jobs will be done by engineers using AI in the future.

Sure a company could fire its engineers and have AI can write the code. But another company could fire everyone else and let the engineers cook with AI.

If they compete, which of those two companies company do you think is going to win? I don't think it's even close.

pinkcoyote |root |parent |previous [-]

You don't see yourself as one of the elite programmers?

Doesn't AI open the possibility for all of us to be better programmers than we were?

markus_zhang |root |parent [-]

Definitely not an elite programmer. I'm improving myself but I'm very average.

But this is actually not the point. Most of the programmers are and will be mediocre, or non-elite ones because it is by comparison.

keiferski |next |previous [-]

I think it’s more like marketers will own the future. If the cost of building stuff gets closer and closer to zero, then the valuable skill is getting attention. In a crowded market, the objective is to stand out.

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent [-]

I'm actually optimistic that AI will allow people to connect with products they're interested in directly and ultimately disrupt advertising platforms.

Think about why we have advertising platforms: because people don't know what's out there that is relevant to them. But if your personal AI agent knows literally everything on the internet, you can find products that meet your needs directly without any extractive middlemen.

The incentive to create this is high because it's way more efficient, but it's obviously going to be a battle with the platforms.

Ultimately though, platforms only exist because it was too hard for people to create their own websites and connect directly over the free and open Internet. With AI that has completely changed so the writing is on the wall.

Even the "Feed" could be dynamically generated for you by your own AI from public content, cutting out the middlemen completely.

keiferski |root |parent [-]

I don’t really think it’s an avoidable problem. In a world of limited attention and lots of people that want it, marketing matters. I’m not referring to paid advertising, I’m referring to doing things that get your business attention.

anonymous_user9 |previous [-]

> Because as a builder/founder, you create value.

Through labor. It seems like you're saying that builders/founders are a special kind of labor that AI cannot replace. Why do you think you're so special?

pacificmaelstrm |root |parent [-]

Let me put it this way:

If you give AI to an doctor, they see more patients, so you need less doctors. If you give AI to a Lawyer, they can do more cases, so you don't need as many lawyers.

If you give AI to an builder they make more new and useful things. So then you want to give even more builders more AI to make more things.

That's the thing about value creation. It's not a zero sum game.

Now maybe you're thinking well why do we need builders when someone can just tell AI to just go make the new and useful things. Great idea. Go build it.