Hacker News

Integrals of Polynomials with Galois Group S_p

10 points by richard_chase ago | 4 comments

richard_chase |next [-]

Some research related to questions I had which I find interesting.

ky3 |previous [-]

The first claim is that given a non-trivial real interval [a,b], then I_[a,b] evaluated over the set of all polynomials with Galois group S_p is unbounded.

The core idea behind the proof is a bit trivial: with something non-zero, one can multiply it to boost it as big as one desires (cue Archimedes).

But where does the bootstrap come from?

Answer: the Osofsky polynomial cited as [1]. But the author forgets that the interval [a,b] is the adversary's choice, not theirs. So said adversary promptly proves there's a non-trivial [a,b] that zeroizes Osofsky.

Poof.

richard_chase |root |parent [-]

Thank you for reading. To your point, I probably should have added that if the Osofsky polynomial integrates to zero on the chosen interval, we can translate it by a suitable rational number and the integral will be non-zero and will still have the same Galois group. I thought that was clear but maybe not. Either way, the claim is valid.

ky3 |root |parent [-]

> we can translate it by a suitable rational number and the integral will be non-zero

You're correct. The main theorem is true, but your write-up has defects.