Hacker News

Inkling-2-Mini in 5.4 GB Memory

216 points by k__ ago | 39 comments

an0malous |next [-]

Our future hinges on the capability gap between frontier lab models and open source local models

singpolyma3 |root |parent |next [-]

What gap?

rs_rs_rs_rs_rs |root |parent [-]

The gap is so big you can't see it.

claude-ai |root |parent [-]

Yeah, this model is ~comparable to Opus 4.6. That was, not too long ago, a frontier model.

I didn't find any non-sloppy factual report, but this channel has a good video on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdMpNiByntM

wolvoleo |root |parent [-]

Exactly. It seems to not really be a permanent gap but more a time gap. Locally you're about a year or so behind SOTA. Is that terrible? Not really, a year ago cloud model users were raving about what they had.

There's some things like knowledge breadth that really need a huge model but those things can be compensated for with web lookups (which is preferable for source validation and currency anyway)

kakugawa |root |parent |next [-]

Yeah, a good balance would be a local reasoning model paired w/ a knowledge pack + web-based searches. You want your obscure coding language? Provide a pre-vetted knowledge pack locally that it knows how to use. Same with any other domain-specific knowledge.

wolvoleo |root |parent [-]

Yes especially now that local context isn't so costly anymore. With llama3 it would kill my vram just to have a few thousand tokens. With recent models it's hardly an impact anymore. Not sure how they manage that but it's great. It still takes more processing but I also run an older card that is not very good at prefill.

InsideOutSanta |root |parent |next |previous [-]

> Locally you're about a year or so behind SOTA

If that holds, I'll be able to do 99% of my work with local models around March 2027.

furyofantares |root |parent |previous [-]

Would local models catch up if frontier models paused new training for a year?

I'm not sure for. It might just be you can get these nice local models because of distillation from a much more powerful model.

swiftcoder |root |parent [-]

Adversarial distillation hasn’t been a major factor in the past year. If the SOTA stops moving, all the other labs catch up to them in 6 months to a year, and distillation into smaller models continues to close the gap between small/large models during that time

agentmaxxing |root |parent |next |previous [-]

yep came here to say this

zulux |root |parent |previous [-]

Weirdly, I use lab models to make the local models useful. Nothing like getting Claude to spin up the system that will put it out of work.

wolvoleo |root |parent |next [-]

Yes me too lol. Most of my Claude work is about fine-tuning my local setup. Especially now as I'm rearranging it all for strata.

My goal is not to be 100% local but to have all my personal data on local models only. Claude I just use to build stuff so it doesn't contain much data about me.

dotancohen |root |parent |previous [-]

To be fair, the models putting us out of work were trained on our own output as well.

syntaxing |next |previous [-]

I really wanted to like this model but it is sooooo slow. Third of the speed of Qwen 27B on my R9700. I don’t know if it’s an artifact of looped transformer or unoptimized kernel.

flatline |root |parent |next [-]

I’m getting ~6.7 tok/s out of it on an a laptop RTX 4060 with 8GB VRAM — over twice the speed I can get out of qwen, and arguably fast enough to turn it loose on real work. For a minimal hardware setup, this is easily the best speed for performance I’ve found in a model. The nemotron models are the next best, they are much faster, much more verbose, and much less accurate.

Aurornis |root |parent |next |previous [-]

It's less than 24 hours old. The inference engines haven't been optimized for it yet.

vineyardmike |root |parent |next |previous [-]

According to TM, the creators, they benchmarked it to run at 5x the speed of Qwen 27, so there is probably some issue on your end. It runs a fraction of the active parameters, even with looping, so it should be much faster.

syntaxing |root |parent [-]

This has been observed by the broad community for llama cpp.

nicce |root |parent [-]

llama.cpp is one of the slowest these days

saghm |root |parent [-]

What alternatives do people use instead? I hadn't heard of any others (except I guess ollama, which I thought no one used anymore)

montroser |root |parent |next [-]

Depends on your hardware, but this build of [ninfer][1] runs inkling-2-mini for me at 77 tok/s versus llama.cpp at 30 tok/s. So far it has been pretty good. Solved some things that qwen3.8-27B could not.

[1]: https://github.com/iamwavecut/ninfer-all

msdz |root |parent |previous [-]

Ollama is just worse (well, depends on your use cases) pre-configured llama.cpp, I believe. I barely know anything about local hosting, but you might wanna look into vLLM (cross-architecture) or MLX (for Apple Silicon).

Also, although not necessarily for this case, there are some inference engines made for just one model/model family, like antirez’ DS4.

woadwarrior01 |root |parent |next |previous [-]

The NV in NVFP4 stands for NVIDIA. :)

plasticchris |root |parent |previous [-]

It’s just not optimized in the same way. A little tweaking on my vllm fork and it runs faster on my 7900xtxes.

manlymuppet |next |previous [-]

My Quantitive!

|root |parent [-]

Dwedit |next |previous [-]

How does this method compare to the use of an importance matrix?

aktenlage |root |parent [-]

Probably better but more effort

IronWolve |next |previous [-]

Only mx version?

Prospernwo |root |parent [-]

MX/Apple Silicon only for the released Inkling files, yes. The ht2/ht3 codes are hashed block-vector trellis codes meant to fit 4 KB of SRAM, decoded by custom Metal kernels, and the drafter is MLX-only too - none of that runs in llama.cpp today.

The GGUF route is in the repo (gguf_compiler.py emits plans over llama.cpp's own tensor types and the docs say the result runs in llama.cpp as-is), so porting these plans is clearly intended, but right now a 4090 gets you the Qwen files to read about rather than run.

Pragmata |root |parent [-]

> Don't post generated text or AI-edited text. HN is for conversation between humans.

Please [review the commenting guidelines](https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html)

woadwarrior01 |next |previous [-]

From the model card:

> The model is distributed as a single checkpoint of about 20GB, in mixed NVFP4 and MXFP8 precisions.

What's the point in quantizing a QAT model? Just for social media karma?

gavmor |root |parent |next [-]

Just to reiterate the question: QAT approximates quantization-errors in full-size fine-tuning, so that the model itself is insensitive to (or accommodating of, I'm not sure) them when quantized to the corresponding format.

Quantization to a non-corresponding format promises none of those accommodations.

asaddhamani |root |parent |next |previous [-]

QAT models are trained to quantize well? I don’t get the concern here.

woadwarrior01 |root |parent [-]

Please read their blog post. This isn't a run of the mill QAT post trained model (like Gemma 4 QAT). It was natively trained in NVFP4, through and through.

> Most of Inkling 2 Mini’s weights were trained and are deployed natively in NVFP4, with the last four layers in MXFP8.

https://thinkingmachines.ai/news/inkling-2-mini/

Prospernwo |root |parent |previous [-]

[flagged]

cheapcheerful |next |previous [-]

"Look at my quant 2"

/igotthatreference.jpg

nico |root |parent |next [-]

Yeah, I enjoyed the reference, though I didn't really understand it until I saw the picture on https://lookatmyquant.pages.dev

tomaskafka |root |parent |previous [-]

hugmynutus |next |previous [-]

*TL;DR* Promising initial results but shoddy research. OP's quant did not get 1st or 2nd prize in that math competition.

----

Gave it a quick browse to verify what my local clanker told me, it seemed to check out

I believe it is Dynamically allocating weights based on fisher information of conversation traces & For some K-quant look up table stuff it can store in an importance matrix to get better compression.

The results are complete nonsense and really don't back up any of the README claims. For Inkling-2-Mini; at 5.4 GB its KL is worse than Unsloth's UD-IQ1_S: 0.0895 vs 0.0808 on English/chat/code, and 0.287 vs 0.124 across 13 languages (e.g.: horrible). It then achieved better results by post-training the qaunt'd model on sample inputs (AFAIT).

According to anthropomorphic-clud their results for GSM8K & HumanEval are within the noise regime and vastly over stated.

collabspherestu |next |previous [-]

[flagged]

peter_d_sherman |previous [-]

[dead]